Pambazuka News 175: The International Monetary Fund and World Bank in Africa: A 'disastrous' record
Pambazuka News 175: The International Monetary Fund and World Bank in Africa: A 'disastrous' record
Hundreds of Congolese refugees in Burundi refused to move to a U.N. camp deeper inside the country and said they wanted to return home after surviving a massacre last month. The U.N High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) planned to move the first group of refugees from temporary transit centres on the border with Congo to a safer site inside Burundi following an ethnic massacre.
The U.N. refugee agency Tuesday criticized Libya for its deportation of Eritreans last month, calling it a "severe violation" of African and international rules of protection. "UNHCR is concerned over the ongoing forcible return of potential refugees from Libya," said Ron Redmond, spokesman for the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. "It also raises concerns over the intentions of the Libyan government to ensure minimum standards of treatment for persons who might be in need of international protection."
The killing remains vivid in their minds. And the deep scars on their bodies will for a long time remind them of the slaughter of their compatriots at a refugee camp in the tiny central African nation of Burundi. These are the survivors of the Aug. 13 massacre at Gatumba refugee camp, about 20 kilometres from Bujumbura, the capital of Burundi.
Deadline: 31 December 2004
The Reebok Human Rights Award recognizes young activists who have made significant contributions to human rights causes through nonviolent means. To this end Reebok welcomes nominees for the "Reebok Human Rights Award."
Organisation Development and Community Management Trust (ODCMT), a grassroots non-governmental organisation has launched a local campaign on cotton trade in Zambia.
The campaign aims at petitioning the Zambian leadership and corporate companies to increase the price of cotton paid to small-scale producers.
It urges for the protection of the health of producers in the use of toxic pesticides and further calls for promotion of socially ethical and environmentally sound practices in investment ventures for sustainable development.
The ODCMT is building on its experience in its participation in a global trade campaign running up to the World Trade Organisation (WTO) ministerial meeting held in Cancun, Mexico.
Its campaign in Zambia resulted in the a massive mobilisation of over 750 000 people, in six months, who joined 4 million others around the globe to petition the world’s most powerful leaders to make trade work for the poor at the last WTO summit.
The Cotton Trade Campaign in Zambia will involve the mobilisation of one million people leading up to the Global Week of Action on trade falling next year between 10-16 April 2005. This global initiative is being spearheaded by the Trade Justice Movement worldwide to eliminate poverty.
The ODCMT’s Campaign and Advocacy programme is being supported by Hivos’ Southern Africa regional office based in Harare. Hivos is an international non-governmental organisation whose headquarters is based in the Netherlands.
The U.N. Children's Fund and the World Food Programme on Tuesday launched a $123 million programme to reduce the mortality rate of children in Ethiopia, one of the world's poorest countries. "The Canadian-funded three-year programme will increase access to health care and supplementary food to benefit six million children in seven regions of Ethiopia during the three year period," a statement issued by UNICEF and WFP said.
A court in Burkina Faso has sentenced a woman to the maximum term of three years in jail for carrying out genital mutilation on 16 girls aged between 2 and 10, court officials said on September 22nd. Campaigners trying to end female circumcision, which is widespread in many African countries, welcomed the sentence and said they hoped it would act as a deterrent to others.
Few horror stories rival the humanitarian crisis in northern Uganda, where a cult-like rebel group has been terrorising local people for a generation. It's a tale of astonishing suffering and massive displacement – and all taking place in a country hailed as one of Africa's development success stories. Yet northern Uganda's nightmare has been largely ignored by the international community, even as the humanitarian crisis in neighbouring Sudan generates hand-wringing worldwide and a steady flow of headlines.
The programme hosts eco-design workshops that train local people and international students together in a knowledge-sharing process. The programme organisers believe that the key to rural poverty alleviation lies in the provision of acceptable housing, access to water and sanitation, creation of local economies, and the development of sustainable livelihoods, preferably based on indigenous knowledge systems and eco-efficient practices.
The overpopulation of elephants in parks throughout southern Africa has reached a crisis stage, most conservationists agree, and South Africa soon will consider whether to cull its herds. It would be the first culling on the continent in a decade. Proponents say it is necessary because the elephants are fast destroying valuable woodlands in many parks, including some 2,000-year-old thick-trunked baobabs.
As the opening speaker of the World Leaders Forum, President Joaquim Alberto Chissano of the Republic of Mozambique discussed his government's efforts to end poverty and called on the international community to help end injustice. In his second address at Columbia University, Chissano, who is also chairman of the African Union, discussed the great strides his country has made toward eradicating poverty by "creating conditions for poverty reduction."
Zimbabwe's information minister has accused the mayor of Bulawayo of lying about food shortages in the second largest city, where independent media have recently reported that scores of people have been dying of hunger. President Robert Mugabe has shut out food aid saying it should be given to more deserving countries.
The United Nations has praised Namibia's efforts to fight desertification in the country by involving communities in the proper use of natural resources. Executive secretary of the UN Convention to Combat Desertification, Hama Arba Diallo, says Namibia has made great strides in the fight against desertification and its experiences could help other Southern African countries.
A dozen French soldiers on mission in Ivory Coast have been placed under investigation for allegedly stealing tens of thousands worth of euros in funds from a bank they were guarding in the west African country. The soldiers, part of France's 4, 000-strong Licorne force in the divided former colony, went before the Armed Forces Tribunal in Paris and were placed under investigation - a step short of being charged - for robbery and receiving stolen goods, the officials said.
At least 11 wild animals, all elephant and buffalo, have died of anthrax in the eastern Caprivi region of Namibia. Sacky Namugongo, deputy director of parks and wildlife management in the environment and tourism ministry, said seven dead elephants and four dead buffaloes were tested on Saturday and Sunday and found to have had anthrax symptoms. The carcasses were found in the areas between Masikili and Kasika in the Caprivi strip and residents have been urged not to eat the meat.
Thousands of people gathered in the small kingdom of Swaziland on September 21st for the first public talks on the country's long-awaited new Constitution. Swaziland was expected to adopt the Constitution before the end of the month, but pro-democracy groups have said the document - which has been in the making since 1996 - did not curb the powers of King Mswati III, but rather strengthened his hold on the poor southern African nation.
An international conference to press for the eradication of female genital mutilation in Africa and around the world took place in Kenya from 16-18 September. A testimony from a thirteen-year-old Kenyan girl was especially shocking as she described what it is like to be forcibly circumcised at the age of 11 to ambassadors, activists, health workers, policy-makers and other guests.
It's back to school in most of West Africa, but in one of the region's poorest and most Islamic countries, Niger, the secular public school system is in a state of paralysis, so more and more children are going to Islamic schools instead. Many impoverished children are forced to go begging to pay for their education.
The Riseau en Afrique Francophone pour la Tilimidecine (Telemedicine Network in French-speaking Africa or RAFT) project is a telemedicine network aimed at creating a multinational South-South network for telemedicine linking healthcare institutions in Francophone African countries. The project provides assistance to culturally adapt online medical content while training medical librarians to improve the quality and accessibility of medical information over the internet.
During a meeting with World Bank officials, Nigerian Education Minister Fabian Osuji outlined his expectations of the World Bank to be more proactive in its support to education. He explained that education was a vital tool for national development, especially in areas of poverty eradication, improvement in health, economic empowerment and job creation. Nigeria's universal basic education (UBE) program is an ambitious one, as it is compulsory and free.
48 teachers in 24 primary schools in and around Cairo, Egypt and the Eastern Cape Province, South Africa followed professional development programmes to integrate a range of ICT-enhanced activities into their teaching of literacy, numeracy and science, supported through workshops and school visits, a range of multimedia resources, as well as through a web environment.
The World Health Organization (WHO) has updated their Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality (GDWQ) which will help pre-empt drinking water contamination. These guidelines will help regulators and water service providers the world over maintain and improve the quality of their drinking water, which could reduce the outbreak of water-borne diseases.
About 20,000 Ogiek live in the Mau Forest in Kenya's Rift Valley province, and also in Mount Elgon Forest in the western part of the country. Authorities sought to remove the Ogiek from their ancestral lands, on the grounds that the community was responsible for environmental degradation. Many viewed this as an attempt to provide land to members of the neighbouring Nandi community in a bid to gain support for government.
King Mswati the Third has announced that construction on the proposed Millennium Airport was to go ahead in his country, against recommendations by the International Monetary Fund that everything should be done to cut non-essential spending in the impoverished nation. Swazi officials insist there is a need for a new international airport capable of accommodating aircraft that are large – and likely to get even bigger over time. However, no business plan has ever been publicly presented to show how the investment would earn a return.
A decade after the advent of democracy in South Africa, and the citizens continue to spend up to 17 dollars a day on prisoners, every day of the year, while babies and toddlers who attend formally-registered preschools get a direct subsidy from the Department of Social Development which averages out at just under 70 cents for every one of the country’s 195 school days.
The first meeting of the power sharing transitional government convened on September 20, 2004 with participants expressing serious concerns about the limited capacity of the government to deliver basic services to Liberians. While Liberia has made remarkable progress towards peace, there is still a lack of adequate funding for the reintegration and rehabilitation of ex-combatants, as well as for the return of refugees and the resettlement of internally displaced persons (IDPs).
According to outgoing French Ambassador to Tanzania, Jean Francois Lionnet, France has cancelled Tanzania's debt of Euro 116 million ($139m) as part of debt relief to the country. In an exclusive interview as his four-year tour of duty comes to an end, Ambassador Lionnet said the main part of the debt, Euro 89 million would simply be written off and the balance converted into additional development programmes, specifically targeting primary education.
In its latest report, the International Crisis Group has warned that if SA and Zimbabwe do not take concrete steps to tackle land reform issues, racial tensions and poverty could rise in the region. The report said that while events in Zimbabwe were unlikely to be replicated in SA soon, it was clear that countries in the region were burdened with chronic land problems that were frustrating attempts to promote economic development and eradicate poverty.
About 50 members of the rights group, Women of Zimbabwe Arise (WOZA), have embarked on a 440 km march to Harare, to protest a proposed bill that will require all NGOs to register with a government-appointed regulatory council and disclose details of their programmes and funding. The proposed legislation also seeks to ban foreign NGOs concerned principally with "issues of governance", and deny registration to NGOs receiving foreign funding for "promotion and protection of human rights and political governance issues".
The World Bank has launched a four-year Country Assistance Strategy Assistance (CAS) in Eastern Province. Through the programme, the bank identifies development programmes it plans to assist with, and relays information to its shareholders for their diagnosis, financial and technical assistance. Within the new CAS programme, the Government is expected to discard the stop-gap economic policy reform process which resulted in structural and implementation hurdles experienced in the past.
During an International Conference on Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) hosted by the Kenyan Government in Nairobi during 16-18 September 2004, several statements were made by government representatives in support of the ratification of the Protocol on the Rights of Women in Africa.
The Kenyan President stated that his country will ratify the Protocol and reliable sources have indicated that the proposal for ratification is currently with the Cabinet.
The Tanzanian Deputy Minister for Community Development, Women's Affairs and Children, Hon. Shamim P. Khan, stated that her country has started the process of ratification and that the Protocol will soon be tabled for consideration by the Parliament.
The Deputy Speaker of Parliament, Hon. Rebecca Kadaga and her delegation which included the Minister of Gender, Labour and Social Affairs, Hon. Bakoko Bakoru Zoe, and a couple of Parliamentarians (Hon. Gertrude Kulany and Hon. Dora Byamukama) committed to convening a meeting for discussion with their colleagues with a view to starting the ratification process.
The Minister for Social Action and National Solidarity from Burkina Faso, Mme Lamizana Mariam, also confirmed that her country has started the ratification process.
The Minister for Labour and Human Welfare from Eritrea, Mrs. Askalu Menkerios, also committed to work on her country's signing and ratification of the Protocol as soon as she returned home.
STOP PRESS STOP PRESS: Le Sénégal a ratifié le Protocole à la CADHP relatif aux Droits de la Femme ! As we go to press, we learn that Senegal has ratified the protocol, making it the fifth country to ratify!
Expanding access to tuberculosis treatment, combined with introducing HIV testing and anti-retroviral (ARV) delivery into TB programmes, could save the lives of as many as 500 000 Africans living with HIV every year and is one of the most cost-effective ways to ensure the survival of HIV-positive people, according to international health experts meeting this week in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
In the tale of the boy who cried wolf, it was the boy himself who suffered the consequences of his actions. This time, it’s two million people in Darfur, writes Salih Booker, executive director of Africa Action. Writing in Foreign Policy in Focus, Booker says the role that the United States played in crying wolf about weapons of mass destruction in Iraq has a direct impact on the current humanitarian crisis in Sudan. "It will be the cruellest irony and the greatest tragedy if the people of Darfur cannot count on the international community to save them from genocide because the country that's the most outspoken against Khartoum is a country that lost its credibility because it cried wolf."
Related Link:
* The "G" Word: Genocide
http://www.fpif.org/commentary/2004/0409gword.html
Increasing girls' access to education and improving women health are two important targets set by the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs). But the simple inclusion of gender in the MDGs should not lead to the assumption that gender issues are now central to development policy and that inequalities will be adequately addressed. Changes in institutional practices, greater monetary investments and creating more opportunities for women - are all needed to make these goals a reality.
The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) look unlikely to be fulfilled. Current rates of progress in improving incomes, health and education across the world are too slow. Under-investment in basic social services by national governments and inadequate support from the international agencies has hampered advancements. Research from the United Nations Development Programme argues that the MDGs are all feasible and affordable but governments and international bodies need to spend more money if they are to be achieved.
This year marks the 60th anniversary of the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank. Through their propaganda machines, both institutions will attempt to highlight their "assistance" to Africa. But in reality, since the 1970s, these institutions have gradually become the chief architects of policies, known as "the Washington Consensus," which are responsible for the worst inequalities and the explosion of poverty in the world, especially in Africa.
Yet, when they began to intervene on that continent in the late 1970s and early 1980s, their stated goal was to "accelerate development", according to a World Bank document, familiarly known as the "Berg Report", published in 1981. But as the following editorial will show, the actual record is just disastrous.
The main pretext for their intervention was to "help solve" the debt crisis that hit African countries in the late 1970s, following the combination of internal and external shocks, notably sharp fluctuations in commodity prices and skyrocketing interest rates. The remedy they proposed, known as stabilization and structural adjustment programs (SAPs), achieved the opposite, and contributed to worsening the external debt and exacerbating the overall economic and social crisis.
In 1980, at the onset of their intervention, the ratios of debt to gross domestic product (GDP) and exports of goods and services were respectively 23.4% and 65.2%. Ten years later, in 1990, they had deteriorated to respectively 63.0% and 210.0%! In 2000, the debt to GDP ratio stood at 71.0% while the ratio of debt to exports of goods and services had "improved" somewhat, at 80.2%, according to the World Bank's Global Development Finance.
The deterioration in debt ratios is reflected in the inability of many African countries to service their external debt. As a result, accumulated arrears on principal and interests have become a growing share of outstanding debt. In 1999, those arrears accounted for 30% of the continent's debt, compared with 15% in the 1990s and 5.0% for all developing countries. To compound the crisis, African countries are getting very little, in terms of new loans, except to pay back old debts. As a result, since 1988, the part of accumulated arrears in "new" debt is estimated at more than 65%.
Between 1980 and 2000, Sub-Saharan African countries had paid more than $240 billion as debt service, that is, about four times the amount of their debt in 1980. Yet, despite this financial hemorrhage, SSA still owes almost four times what its owed more than twenty years ago! One of the most striking illustrations of this apparent paradox is the case of the Nigerian debt. In 1978, the country had borrowed $5 billion. By 2000, it had reimbursed $16 billion, but still owed $31 billion, according to President Obasanjo.
The Nigerian case is a good example of the structural nature of Africa's debt crisis and of the power imbalance that characterizes world economic and financial relationships. It is this general context that allowed the IMF and World Bank to increase their influence in African countries. One good illustration of this has been the rapid rise in the share of the World Bank and its affiliate, the International Development Association (IDA), in SSA's debt. The combined share of both, which was barely 5.1% of SSA's total debt in 1980, had jumped to 25.0% in 1990 and to more than 37% in 2000, according to the World Bank. In other words, the World Bank group has become the principal "creditor" of many Sub-Saharan countries, which explains the enormous sway it holds over these countries' policies.
One way they exercise this influence is through the imposition of stiff conditionalities on African countries in exchange for loans and credits. Financial liberalization, aimed at attracting more foreign investments to compensate for shortfalls in export revenues, instead fostered more instability, due to the volatility of exchange rates resulting from speculative short-term capital flows. This, combined with higher interest rates, "crowded" out both public and private investments. For instance, investments as a percentage of gross domestic production (GDP) fell from an annual average of 23% between 1975 and 1979 to an average of 18% between 1980 and 1984 and 16% between 1985 and 1989. They recovered somewhat in the 1990s, but averaged only 18.2% between 1990 and 1997, according to UNCTAD. These statistics are consistent with those given by the World Bank, which show that the annual investment ratio averaged 18.6% and 17.2% in 1981-1990 and 1991-2000, respectively.
These low investment ratios resulted in a contraction of output. Real GDP growth, which averaged 3.5 % in the 1970s, fell to 1.7%, between 1981 and 1990, according to the World Bank. However, this masks the sharp declines recorded in the 1980s, dubbed "the lost decade" for Africa. This is better illustrated by the negative growth rates of both GDP and consumption per capita. They fell respectively by 1.2% and 0.9% a year between 1981 and 1990. It is estimated that in 1981-1989, the cumulative loss of per capita income for the continent as a whole was equivalent to more than 21% of real GDP.
In a report released in September 2001, UNCTAD indicated that the average income per capita in SSA was 10% lower in 2000 than its 1980 level. In monetary terms, average income per capita fell from $522 in 1981 to $323 in 1997, a loss of nearly $200. The same report said that rural areas experienced an even greater decline in income. These statistics were confirmed by the World Bank, which says that income per capita in Sub Saharan Africa contracted by a cumulative 13% between 1981 and 2001.
The 2004 edition of the World Development Indicators says that SSA is the only region in the world where poverty has continued to rise since the early 1980s, that is at the onset of IFIs' intervention. According to that document, in 1981, an estimated 160 million people lived on less than $1 a day. In 2001, the number had risen to 314 million, almost double its 1981 level. This means that approximately 50% of Africa's population lives in poverty. When the threshold is $2 a day, the numbers rise from 288 million to 518 million, during the same period.
The costs of trade liberalization
According to the IMF and World Bank, one of the sources of Africa's crisis is its inward-looking trade system, characterized by the protection of domestic markets, subsidies, overvalued exchange rates and other "market distortions" that made African exports less "competitive" in world markets. In place of this system, they propose an open and liberal trading system in which tariff and non tariff barriers are kept to a minimum or even eliminated. Such a system, combined with an export-led growth strategy, would put Africa on a solid path to economic recovery, according to both institutions.
The costs associated with trade liberalization have largely offset any potential "benefits" African countries were supposed to derive from that liberalization. First of all, trade liberalization has translated into substantial fiscal losses, since many countries depend on import taxation as their main source of fiscal revenues. Therefore, the elimination of, or reduction in, import tariffs has led to lower government revenues.
But one of the most negative impacts of trade liberalization has been the collapse of many domestic industries, unable to sustain competition from powerful and subsidized competitors from industrialized countries. In fact, Africa's industrial sector has been among the biggest victims of structural adjustment.
From Senegal to Zambia, from Mali to Tanzania, from Cote d'Ivoire to Uganda, entire sectors of the domestic industry have been wiped out, with devastating consequences. Not only has the industrial sector contribution to domestic product continued to fall, but also the industrial workforce has continued to shrink dramatically. In Senegal, more than one third of industrial workers lost their jobs in the 1980s. The trend was accentuated in the 1990s, following sweeping trade liberalization policies and privatization imposed by the IMF and the World Bank, especially after the 50% devaluation of the CFA Franc, in 1994. In Ghana, the industrial workforce declined from 78,700 in 1987 to 28,000 in 1993. In Zambia, in the textile sector alone, more than 75% of workers lost their jobs in less than a decade, as a result of the complete dismantling of that sector by the Chiluba presidency. In other countries, such as Cote d'Ivoire, Burkina Faso, Mali, Togo, Zambia, Tanzania, etc. similar trends can be observed.
In several annual and special reports, the International Labor Organization (ILO) has documented the devastating impact of SAPs on employment and wages. The African Union seems to have come to grips with that devastation. It organized a special Summit on Employment and Poverty, in the capital of Burkina Faso, September 9 and 10, 2004. It was revealed during that Summit that only 25% of the African workforce is employed in the formal sector. The rest, 75%, is either in the subsistence agriculture or in the informal sector. In light of this reality, the Summit issued a Plan of Action aimed at exploring strategies to foster job creation. But such a Plan will only be credible if African countries are ready to move away from IMF and World Bank recipes, which were harshly criticized during the Summit.
UNCTAD has reported that more than 70% of Africa's exports are still composed of primary products, more than 62% of which are non processed products. This helps justify the need for more liberalization and deregulation to make African exports more "competitive". The second objective is to help justify the need for more liberalization and deregulation to make African economies more "competitive" and "attractive" to foreign direct investments. This also explains the push for more privatization.
In the name of "comparative advantage", the export-led growth strategy forces African countries to compete fiercely for market shares, leading them to flood the same markets with more of their commodities. As a result, trade liberalization has accentuated the volatility of African commodities, whose prices experienced twice the volatility of East Asian commodity prices and nearly four times the volatility that industrial countries experienced in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s. This has contributed to worsening Africa's terms of trade.
According to UNCTAD, if Africa's terms of trade had remained at their 1980 level:
- Africa's share in world trade would have been twice its current level
- the investment ratio would have been raised by 6.0% per annum in non-oil exporting countries
- it would have added to annual growth 1.4% per annum
- it would have raised GDP per capita by at least 50% to $478 in 1997 compared with the actual figure of $323 during that year.
The costs of financial liberalization
One of the main objectives of financial liberalization is to make African countries "attractive" to foreign direct investments. But as the experience of development shows, foreign direct investments follow development, not the other way around. In addition, despite all "the right financial policies", foreign investments continue to elude Africa, with less than 2% of flows to developing countries, despite having among the highest rates of return on investments in the world. And these flows are concentrated in a few oil-producing and mineral-rich countries, according to UNCTAD and the World Bank.
In reality, financial liberalization has yielded little gains. For most African countries, it has been associated with huge costs. First, it entails higher levels of foreign exchange reserves to protect domestic currencies against attacks resulting from speculative short-term capital outflows. Second, financial liberalization has increased the likelihood of capital flight, in part as a result of a greater volatility of domestic currencies. The high costs of trade and financial liberalization further weakened African economies and opened the way to the privatization of the continent.
The privatization of Africa
Privatization, like financial liberalization, is seen by the IMF and World Bank as an instrument to promote private sector development, which has been elevated to the status of "engine of growth". The privatization of State-owned enterprises (SOEs), including water and power utilities, has been one of the core conditionalities imposed by the two institutions, even in the context of "poverty reduction".
Most of the foreign direct investments registered by African countries in the 1990s came as a response to privatization of SOEs. No sector was spared, even those considered as "strategic" in the 1980s, such as telecommunications, energy, water and the extractive industries. In 1994, the World Bank published a report assessing the process of privatization in SSA. After complaining about the slow pace of privatization throughout the region, it issued a warning to African governments to accelerate the dismantling of their public sector, accused of being "at the heart of Africa's economic crisis". The process of privatization peaked in the late 1990s and ever since has leveled off, despite more deregulation, liberalization and all kinds of incentives offered to would be investors.
To date, it is estimated that more than 40,000 SOEs have been sold off in Africa. However, the "gains" from privatization, projected by the World Bank and the IMF, have been elusive. In fact, many privatization schemes have failed and contributed to worsening economic and social conditions. Almost everywhere, privatization has been associated with massive job losses and higher prices of goods and services that put them out of reach of most citizens.
Building a neoliberal State
The concept of "good governance" was promoted by the IMF and World Bank to explain the failure of SAPs. It tends to convey the idea that SAPs have failed, in large part, because African States are "corrupt", "wasteful" and "rent-seeking" and because of the "poor implementation" of policies. In other words, SAPs were basically "sound", it is the combination of "rampant corruption" and lack of qualified personnel that led to the failure of these policies. Thus, "good governance" means nothing else than the need to build a neoliberal State, subservient to the IFIs, able to effectively implement, "sound policies" and to protect the interests of foreign investors.
Indeed, one of the main goals of the IMF and World Bank has been to discredit State-led development strategies in favor of market-led strategies. This is why one of the main targets of these institutions has been the role of the African State in economic and social development. To discredit that role, a two-track strategy was adopted. The first track was to attack the credibility of the African State as an agent of development. To achieve that goal, an abundant literature has been published by the two institutions, highlighting the "corrupt", "predatory", "wasteful" and "rent-seeking" nature of the African State. To justify these epithets, the IFIs pointed to the "mismanagement" of the public sector, accused of being an obstacle to economic growth and development. These attacks helped make the case for the sweeping restructure of the public sector, which, in many cases, led to its dismantling in favor of the private sector.
The second track in weakening the role of the State in development was to deprive it of financial resources. Trade and financial liberalization achieved in part that goal. As already indicated, trade liberalization not only led to a greater loss of fiscal revenues, following lower tariff barriers, but it also led to huge trade losses. This was compounded by financial liberalization which entailed further fiscal losses resulting from tax holidays and low income tax rates. To make up for these losses, the African State had to resort to more and more multilateral and bilateral loans and credits, which further alienated its sovereignty.
As a result, many African States have been stripped of all but a handful of their economic and social functions. Cuts in spending mostly fell on social sectors. State retrenchment primarily aimed at eliminating subsidies for the poor, removing social protection, and abandoning its role in fighting for social justice through income redistribution and other social transfers to the most disadvantaged segments of society. This explains, among other things, the degradation of many basic social services and the explosion of poverty in Africa, since 1981, as the World Bank itself has acknowledged.
While dismantling or weakening the economic and social roles of the State, the IMF and World Bank have sought to build or strengthen the functions most useful to the implementation of neoliberal policies and the promotion of private sector development. This explains the insistence on "capacity building" or on "institution building", heard over the last few years. However, the institutions that the IMF and World Bank talk about are not for development, but for markets. In other words, they propose building institutions supportive of neoliberal policies and in the service of the private sector, especially foreign investors.
Thus, the "institution building" agenda promoted by the IMF and the World Bank has nothing to do with promoting democracy and protecting human rights. In fact, the neoliberal conception of governance undermines both since it deprives representative institutions of their role in formulating public policies following open and democratic debates. They are reduced to implementing what the IMF and World Bank and their G 8 masters decide for African countries and their people.
From structural adjustment to poverty "reduction"
After producing poverty and deprivation on a massive scale in Africa and elsewhere, the IFIs' focus on "poverty reduction" since 1999 could not be more suspect. But to make this shift a bit more credible, the IMF's Enhanced Structural Adjustment Facility (ESAF) was renamed "Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility" (PRGF) and the World Bank has set up a "Poverty Reduction Support Credit" (PRSC).
There is no doubt that the shift in the rhetoric of the IFIs amounts to an admission of failure of past policies, which put too much emphasis on correcting macroeconomic imbalances and "market distortions" at the expense of economic growth and social progress. The disastrous record of SAPs and the continued deterioration in the economic and social situation of countries subjected to IMF and World Bank programs put into question the credibility and even the legitimacy of these institutions. Their crisis of legitimacy was exacerbated by stepped up attacks by the Global Justice Movement and growing criticism from mainstream economists, especially from Joseph E. Stiglitz, former World Bank Chief Economist.
The nature of Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs)
The PRSPs are supposed to provide more freedom to developing countries in formulating their policies. This is what the Bank and the Fund call "national ownership." Representatives from the government, the private sector, civil society organizations - and even the poor - are supposed to "participate" in drafting the PRSP of each country to decide on how to use the proceeds released by "debt relief" to achieve "poverty reduction".
In reality, the macroeconomic framework that underpins the PRSPs is the same as that which underpinned the now discredited SAPs. That framework is non negotiable and includes fiscal austerity, trade and financial liberalization, privatization, deregulation and State retrenchment, etc. In essence, despite the disastrous outcome of their past policies, the IMF and the World Bank still believe that those policies are in the "interests of the poor". In particular, they think that trade liberalization and openness are the best - if not the only - road to growth, which they see as a "prerequisite" for poverty reduction. Hence the export-led growth strategy advocated by the two institutions, but which has been a big failure in African and other developing countries.
A survey of 27 African PRSPs by UNCTAD in 2002 has demonstrated that all of them, without exception, contain the policies outlined above. Policies which are at odds with both the wishes and the interests of the poor, observes the document. It is this straight jacket that ties up developing countries' hands and prevents them from achieving any substantial gain in poverty "reduction". Most of the time, countries have failed to implement these conditions, leading to the suspension of their programs.
In fact, the IFIs' conception of poverty views it as an isolated aspect of overall economic and social development that should be dealt with by short-term measures. Hence, the emphasis in the PRSPs on more spending for primary education and health, among others. Thus, PRSPs contain some short-term measures aimed at mitigating the negative impact of macroeconomic policies and structural reforms on the most vulnerable groups, notably the poor. However, the tools the World Bank and the IMF have proposed to achieve this goal are the same as those already tested in the past and that have aggravated poverty and deprivation in much of Africa.
In reality, PRSPs are SAPs with more conditionalities and less resources. As already indicated, a new "generation" of conditionalities have been added to old conditionalities, with the concept of "good governance", analyzed above. UNCTAD (2002) has revealed that between 1999 and 2000, 13 African countries had signed programs containing an average of 114 conditionalities, 75% of which are governance-related conditionalities. One can imagine the enormous human and financial resources needed to deal with such a number of conditionalities. For this reason, the degree of compliance with IMF and World Bank-sponsored programs has significantly declined since the mid-1990s. For instance, the rate of compliance was estimated at about 28% of the 41 agreements signed between 1993 and 1997, according to UNCTAD.
With the PRSPs, the IMF and the World Bank pursue three objectives. First, mislead world public opinion, especially in Northern countries, in making believe that they are really serious about "reducing poverty". And the World Bank alone counts on a huge and sophisticated propaganda machine to achieve this. With the more than 300 staff of its External Relations Department - Propaganda Department, one should say - the Bank has all the means it needs to "explain" effectively its policies. It has achieved some success, since some big Northern NGOs, once very critical of SAPs, see the PRSPs as a "positive shift" in the IFIs' policies.
The second objective of the PRSPs is to enlist a broad support within each country to help rehabilitate discredited and failed policies. This is what "national ownership" and "participation" of civil society organizations are supposed to achieve. While insisting on the "participation" of civil society organizations, their most vocal critics, the IMF and World Bank tend to sideline representative institutions, like National Assemblies. This is another illustration of these institutions' contempt for the democratic process in Africa. Finally, with PRSPs, the IMF and the World Bank seek to shift the blame to African countries and citizens for the inevitable failure of these "new" policies.
Conclusion
The IMF and World Bank have utterly failed in "reducing poverty" and "promoting development". In fact, they are instruments of domination and control in the hands of powerful states whose long-standing objective is to perpetuate the plunder of the resources of the Global South, especially Africa. In other words, the fundamental role of the Bank and Fund in Africa and in the rest of the developing world is to promote and protect the interests of global capitalism.
This is why they have never been interesting in "reducing" poverty, much less in fostering "development". As institutions, their ultimate objective is to make themselves "indispensable" in order to strengthen and expand their power and influence. They will never relinquish easily that power and influence. This explains why they have perfected the art of duplicity, deception and manipulation. In the face of accumulated failures and erosion of their credibility and legitimacy, they have often changed their rhetoric, but never their fundamental goals and policies.
This is why they cannot be trusted to bring about "development" in Africa. If the experience of the last quarter of a century has taught Africa one fundamental lesson it is that the road to genuine recovery and development begins with a total break with the failed and discredited policies imposed by the IMF and the World Bank.
In fairness to both institutions, we must recognize, however, the complicity of African leaders in the disastrous outcome of neoliberal policies. Many governments and senior civil servants have bought into the agenda promoted by the IMF and World Bank. Therefore, they bear a great responsibility in the current state of the continent. Thus, to put an end to the influence of these institutions, African social movements and progressive forces must explore strategies aimed at promoting a new kind of leadership able and willing to challenge these institutions in favor of genuine alternative development policies.
* Demba Moussa Dembele is Director of the Forum for African Alternatives in Dakar, Senegal
* Please send comments to
HIGHLIGHTS FROM THIS ISSUE
* Editorial: The International Monetary Fund and World Bank in Africa: A 'disastrous' record
* Comment and Analysis: A happy birthday?: The Chad/Cameroon oil pipeline one year on
* Letters: Debate on FGM continues
* Conflicts and Emergencies: What's going on in Northern Uganda?
* Human Rights: Diego Garcia: Fighting for the right to return
* Refugees and Forced Migration: 'Killers' guarding Sudan refugees
* Women and Gender: Protocol on the Rights of Women in Africa: Ratification process update: STOP PRESS: Senegal becomes fifth country to ratify the Protocol!
* Corruption: Nigerian Govt blacklists U.S. oil firm, Halliburton
* HIV/AIDS: Saving lives through combination treatment
* Environment: Nigeria: Either legal or illegal, commercial logging in Cross River State forest must be banned
* News from the Diaspora: Can Black studies Programs survive?
SMS FOR WOMEN'S RIGHTS
* Use your mobile phone to sign the petition in support of the ratification of the Protocol on the Rights of Women in Africa. Send a message to: +27832933934, with the word 'petition' and your name in the message. You will only be charged the cost set by your network provider for sending an international SMS. More information http://www.pambazuka.org/petition/smssocial.php or sign online at http://www.pambazuka.org/petition/
* Sign up for FREE SMS ALERTS about the campaign for the ratification of the Protocol on the Rights of Women in Africa. Visit http://www.pambazuka.org/petition/alerts.php
HOW TO SUPPORT THE SMS PETITION
* Send text messages to your colleagues and friends alerting them to the petition and informing them how to sign by SMS. You can also use email and word of mouth to help spread the word.
A major hospital in Botswana is struggling to cope with the mounting pressure of staff and resource shortages, the HIV/AIDS crisis and a high rate of road accidents. The Princess Marina hospital was initially meant to be a referral facility for districts south of the capital, Gaborone, but has evolved into a national referral centre due to the lack of specialised units in the rest of the country.
Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF) and the Central African Republic (CAR) have embarked on a two-year project to provide low cost malaria treatment in the remote eastern province of Haut Mbomou, boosting countrywide efforts to fight the killer disease. "Now we have [the] necessary means to fight malaria in Haut Mbomou," Dr Daniel-Florent Dignito, the head of medical services in the province, told IRIN on September 21st. "The new low cost treatment of malaria in Haut Mbomou is aimed at assisting the deprived population."
While the Kenyan government was hosting an international conference on female genital mutilation (FGM) in Nairobi between 16-18 September, two Kenyan sisters mutilated two weeks before were calling for justice in their case. Santeyian and Dorcas Keiwua, 16 and 14 years old, respectively, were cut on August 28, 2004 in their home in Orkiriaine at Lolonga Division of Narok District.
On Friday, October 10 2003, before African head of states and foreign dignitaries in Kome, Chad, President Idriss Deby symbolically turned the tap that opened the flow of 225 000 barrels of oil. The $3.7 billion crown jewel project of the World Bank (WB) is the biggest foreign investment in sub-Sahara Africa. For the next 25 years, approximately 900 million barrels of oil will be pumped from 300 oil wells drilled in Doba, south of Chad, along a 1070km pipeline to Cameroon on the Atlantic coast.
WB financing, which totalled just 4 percent of the cost, was crucial to the project. The oil consortium comprising of Exxon, Petronas, and Chevron considered the participation of WB as a necessary political risk insurance, which enabled them to raise more money on international capital markets. Meanwhile, the WB embraced the project as an unparalleled opportunity for land-locked Chad to lift its 6.5 million population out of acute poverty, and for ocean-bordered Cameroon to generate much needed revenues.
Some months after Chad, the world's fifth poorest country, entered the pantheon of Africa's petro-states, it is worth taking stock of the overall project impacts now that the exploitation phase has started. Has the project broken free from the traditional gap between expectations and dismal realities of oil exploitation? Better still, has the oil been a Weapon of Mass Poverty (WMP) or a Weapon of Mass Development (WMD) to Chad and Cameroon?
The background to any petroleum project is key in determining the development outcomes. In fact, the underlying development problems associated with the extraction of black gold are not inherent in the resource itself. However, there is little disagreement on the ability of oil to ratchet up pre-existing conflict in a society; oil can become the very rationale for starting war. In this light, the socio-political environment in which WB approved the project was a potent recipe for poor development outcomes.
There is an endemic mix of corruption and civil strife in Chad and Cameroon. For instance, Chad, since independence, has been marred by a vicious cycle of conflicts and war. Besides the absence of basic ingredients for the growth of civil society, elections are shamelessly rigged, fraud is rife, and the regimes have shown a predilection to violently repress dissenting voices.
For example, villagers were coerced to give their accord to the project in consultations prior to its approval. Tales in Kome, where villagers were consulted in the presence of government forces and rebels, are all too glaring. The village chief was imprisoned for his unfavourable attitude, and the oil company representative arrived accompanied with military police. Given this background, most people were too intimidated to speak out against the project.
Given that Cameroon has consecutively crowned Transparency International's rating of the most corrupt countries in the world, it was no surprise that a bellicose climate of non- information disclosure concerning the project was the norm.
International civil society organisations in 1997 argued for the project's postponement to ensure the two countries upgrade their governance capacities. Contrarily, WB in June 2000 discounted this burgeoning corruption and civil strife in Cameroon and Chad respectively to approve the project. Shortly after, civil society partners were proved right when the Chadian government, on receiving $25 million from the project consortium as a signature bonus, admitted to have used the money in procuring arms to quell a rebel insurgence in the north of the country.
More recently, soon after the project's official inauguration last October, the government closed down the country's only independent radio station, FM Liberté, which had close ties to the country's human rights organisations. Then residents of the capital city, Ndjamena, witnessed the first public executions in more than a decade after court trails which human rights groups described as a mockery of justice. Hence, a warning signal to critical voices in the country to stay quiet.
It is worth noting that the WB's own Operations and Evaluation Department (OED) review commissioned in 2001 finds the Bank wanting on issues of governance. The review points out that while the WB is aware of the underlying causes for the underperformance of resource-rich countries, it has yet to formulate and implement viable approaches to address them. The recently released report of the WB sponsored Extractive Industry Review, primed the role of governance in shaping development outcomes of oil projects. Unequivocally, it recommended the WB to stop support for petroleum projects in areas of conflict or at high risk of conflict.
Broken livelihoods and promises
Approximately 880 km of the pipeline traverses Cameroon's fragile ecological zones. These include one of Africa's unique coastal rainforests, home to several indigenous peoples. Before the commencement of the construction phase, thousands of affected peoples living in villages and communities along the route of the pipeline were identified for eventual compensations. One hundred and fifty families were singled out for resettlement. Many village lands were expropriated, crops and plants destroyed and water sources polluted. The compensation plan, that included individual and communal compensations, was very limited in scope and inadequate to restore or improve on broken livelihoods.
Despite compensation being paid to replace agricultural land, most of the funds did not go into agricultural production or reinvestment to make provision for the future. The affected communities have been left alone with little or no skills to face the long-term impacts: funds had no impact in terms of generating new livelihoods for villagers; prices have increased due to shortage of labour and agricultural goods on the market; rural-urban exodus has increased and conflicts between locals and migrants attracted by the new found wealth have also increased.
The communal compensation plan, which had as its objective to compensate communities with social development projects, was very limited. Communities, who were supposed to identify projects themselves through consultations, were instead constrained to choose from a restrictive list of options proposed by the consortium.
The project thus raises a crucial issue: that of balancing profits with ecological and social principles in petroleum exploitation. Driven by the ethos of cost minimisation, the consortium was motivated to fast-track its operations, while time-intensive social and environmental components such as capacity building lag on. To what extent therefore can multinational corporations be constrained to synchronise the evolution of their exploitation operations with that of social and environmental safeguards?
Turning oil revenue into long-term benefits for the masses is the most contentious issue in resource-rich countries, particularly in Africa. Ultimately, this depends on the quality of public policy. The WB prides the revenue oversight mechanism in the Chad-Cameroon pipeline as an innovation to the extractive industry.
Under pressure from WB, the Chadian government decreed a petroleum management law in 1998. The law provides for the following division of the $2 billion royalties and dividends that would accrue from the project in the next 25 years: 10 percent set aside in a future generation-fund to prepare Chad for a post-oil future; the remaining 90 percent would pass through an offshore petroleum revenue account; 80 percent of which would go to five priority sectors (health, rural development, education, infrastructure, and environmental and water resources); 5 percent would go to the Doba oil producing region; and the remaining would be used by the Chadian government to tackle pressing operational needs.
To mainstream transparency, accountability, and participation, an oversight committee, comprising representatives from civil society, government, administration, and the judiciary was created to monitors the flows and approve spending from the offshore account.
Undoubtedly, this initiative is laudable. However, there are some flaws, which incapacitate it. For instance, three months after Chad started to taste the oil revenues, the committee lacked basic office facilities. In addition, the 5 percent allocated to the Doba region is inadequate. Worst of all, the allocations contained in the law can be changed by the government unilaterally after five years.
In addition, the law covers only direct revenues generated from royalties while indirect revenues such as taxes and customs duties are precluded. These could account for up to 45 percent of the total oil revenues expected over the lifetime of the project.
Conclusion
Several conclusions about petroleum development in Africa become apparent from the Chad-Cameroon pipeline project.
Firstly, oil corporations cannot be transformed into development agencies even with the best of intentions and monitoring mechanisms. Secondly, global wielders of development outcomes like the WB cannot exercise sufficient clout on the penchant for profits of oil multinationals. Thirdly, WB is incapable of respecting even its own weakening safeguard policies, which are premised on controlling damage rather than avoiding harm.
Fourthly, the embryonic neoliberal governance structures in Africa are incapable of constraining Foreign Direct Investments, which are principally attracted by ground mineral resources, to respect ecological and social principles. The flawed contention of the WB is "one cannot eat omelettes without breaking some eggs'' but the eggs are more often the poor who end up with no livelihood opportunity and become even poorer.
Finally, Public Private Partnerships (PPP), the buzz paradigm of sustainable development, are fundamentally incapable of readdressing the unequal power relations between fattening multinationals, weakening states and the World Bank.
As it turns sixty, it is time therefore to pressure the Bank to retire from financing development and environmental disasters like the pipeline. In sum, just like the Weapons of Mass Destruction in Iraq, the Chad-Cameroon pipeline is an illusive Weapon of Mass Development. It is time to send some United Nations development experts to Chad and Cameroon to uncover Weapons of Mass Poverty.
* Akong Charles Ndika is an energy policy analyst with Global Village Cameroon
In addition to humanitarian updates, the Relief Web Site publishes updated job vacancies. To subscribe email [email protected] or submit request at http://www.reliefweb.int/vacancies/. Applications for positions should be sent directly to the organisation in question.
Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe has accused US leader George W Bush of behaving as though he is God, with UK Prime Minister Tony Blair his prophet. He said the US and the UK were "raining bombs and hell-fire on innocent Iraqis, purportedly in the name of democracy."
PAMBAZUKA NEWS 174: DEBATING FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION
PAMBAZUKA NEWS 174: DEBATING FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION
"I will create a desk in both the President's Office and Foreign Affairs to coordinate the affairs of Ugandans in the diaspora. I am studying the question of parliamentary representation...and any other areas of Ugandan concentration in the diaspora. On the strategic issues the Movement has been facing." This is according to a recent speech by Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni.
The 2004 AFRICA'S BRAIN GAIN Nairobi Conference: "Facilitating Return of Talents to Africa through Project Collaboration", a conference for the Diaspora, Universities, Governments, NGOs, Development Partners, and the Private Sector to be held at the Safari Park Hotel, Nairobi, Kenya, 19th - 22nd December 2004.
The United Network of Young Peacebuilders (UNOY Peacebuilders) will be hosting their annual African Student Conference on October 2nd 2004, atThe Hague in The Netherlands. Designed for African students studying in the Netherlands, African Youth Diaspora and Dutch students interested in Africa, the theme this year is Youth Building Peace in Africa: Inclusion, Empowerment, Action.
Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights and the Legal Resources Foundation are contemplating a class action to compel Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe to publish findings of investigations into military atrocities against civilians in Matabeleland in the 1980s. A spokesperson for the two human rights groups said they were still collecting signatures from victims of an alleged genocidal campaign in Zimbabwe’s Matabeleland and Midlands provinces that claimed the lives of an estimated 20 000 people in five years.
A growing number of NGOs and education activists are recognizing that good teachers are the key to educational success, and the Education For All goals will never be achieved unless governments invest more in teachers. If you share this view why not let your government know by organising local events linked to World Teachers’ Day on 5 October.
The world's developing nations have made "significant progress” in reducing extreme poverty and alleviating hunger and disease, says U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan, in an year-end review of the U.N.'s much-publicised Millennium Development Goals (MDGs). But he warns that progress has been hardest to come by in the 50 ”least developed countries” (LDCs) - described as the poorest of the world's poor - 34 of which are in sub-Saharan Africa. These LDCs range from Afghanistan and Bangladesh to Sierra Leone and Zambia.
For foreign students at Newcastle University, especially Asians and Africans, abuse, vilification and even physical attacks are commonplace. "Students are worried - not scared, but worried - about the situation," said Chilean Veronica Meneses, the university's welfare officer for international students.
“It is time to do away with the niceties, to get back to 'rights language' and for women to stop asking men to be nice, as though they are doing them a favour when it comes to women's issues." This is the tough talk from Zimbabwean feminist Everjoice Win, who was in Durban recently to give a lecture at the University of KwaZulu-Natal. Win believes that "gender language" does the (women's) cause no good, and cautions that politicians use events like Women's Day as a platform for their own agendas.
The Chief Directorate: Population and Development, South Africa, would like to set up an email information service to various organizations in Southern Africa and send out information to them regarding regional issues such as poverty, HiV/Aids, youth, gender, environment, population, development and other topics of relevance. If your organisation is interested in joining such a list, please send Carol Lombard an email at: [email protected].
Simon Mann, the leader of the failed coup attempt in Equatorial Guinea, has started a seven-year jail sentence in Zimbabwe for trying to buy weapons from Zimbabwe's state arms manufacturer. A court in Harare ruled that the Old Etonian and former SAS officer should stay behind bars until 2011, crushing his hopes that British establishment figures could use their money and influence to secure his freedom.
According to a nation-wide survey conducted between 20 and 28 May 2004, by the Ghana Centre for Democratic Development (CDD-Ghana) and the National Democratic Institute (NDI), the Ghanaian democratic system is being threatened by corruption, both by political parties as well as the citizens who support them.
Once dismissed as a puppet of Malawi’s former president, new leader Bingu wa Mutharika is being praised for his anti-corruption initiatives since he took office in June. Mutharika hopes to fight corruption and eventually win back tens of millions of dollars in foreign aid that were cut off in June 2002 by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), donor countries, and from former colonial ruler Britain, due to concerns over spending.
The Government of Benin has been unable to control the illegal sale of petroleum products in Benin, which are often smuggled from neighboring Nigeria. This black market trade has caused Beninese fuel distribution companies to lose 50 percent of their share of the Beninese market and has led to numerous health concerns and human casualties.
Your interview with Rudy Amenga-Etego is worthy of commendation (Pambazuka News 171). I completely agree with him that the privatisation of water is not the best option for Ghana and Africa in general, which has no welfare provisions. It goes to show the failure on the part of African Governments to provide for the people they are supposed to govern. The failure of these essential amenities are due largely to the corruption that has become endemic in governance in Africa. The privatisation of water will further impoverish the people who have no means of livelihood. The act should be resisted.
In the letter section of last week's edition (Pambazuka News 173), Thomas Mountain wrote that Eritrea is the only country in Africa to start winning the war against HIV/AIDS with the drop in its infection rate.
I however take issue with Thomas for writing that Eritrea "is the only country in Africa to start winning the war against HIV/AIDS by reducing HIV/AIDS infection rates from 3% to 2.5%". While this is good news for Africa - that we are emerging on top of the scourge that continues to claim lives endlessly - Uganda was in fact the first country to start winning the war on the continent and it is today noted as Africa's role model in this regard.
Ghana has also recently recorded a drop in infection rates from 3.6% to 2.9%.
Several other countries continue to record drops in their infection rates, including South Africa where the rate has been the highest on the continent.
Keep up the good work with Pambazuka News. It's a great read!
As sub-Saharan Africa’s biggest oil producer after Nigeria, Angola is slowly coming clean on its oil revenue due to donor pressure. In order to receive more funding from the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and other international capital markets, Angola must provide more accountability of its oil revenue.
Thank you for your excellent publication. I have been subscribing for several years and always find many things of interest. I use your section on fundraising to trace down possible donors for a conservation program I sponsor in Africa. Several times now I have found something that interests me on the Thusanang website. However, the url you publish only takes you to the home page. It is a difficult job to find the specific article cited because there are so many categories listed and one does not know which to choose from. May I suggest that you include the URL for the specific topic within the website?
PZ REPLIES: In the case of a text email, the URL is often split between two lines, with only the first line showing an active URL. Readers with this problem may find it useful to cut the entire URL and paste it into the address line of their internet browser.
I recently watched here in Europe on TV a documentary about a French surgeon who has found a way to reconstitute the clitoris after Female Genital Mutilation. His name is Pierre Foldes. I am sure you have heard about, but anyway I attach a link to a newspaper article about him:
I enjoy Pambazuka News very much. Have you considered a section on children? While I realize many issues touch children, I believe their importance warrants separate consideration.
PZ REPLIES: At this stage we are not considering expanding our existing sections although we agree that the issue of child rights is an important one. We do include many stories on children in our education and social welfare sections and we have previously carried editorials which focus on children.
The Chairman of the Independent Corrupt Practices Commission (ICPC), Justice Mustapha Akanbi, stated that it would not be possible for the Commission to prosecute past heads of state, such as former President General Ibrahim Babangida, with corruption as this would be considered retroactive legislation and undemocratic.
At least 100 people have been killed and more than 6,000 displaced from their homes in Nigeria's oil city of Port Harcourt as a result of gang violence over the past month and attempts by the security forces to suppress it, a local human rights group said on Friday. The Lagos-based Committee for the Defence of Human Rights (CDHR) said thousands of residents in Port Harcourt and nearby villages had been forced to flee their homes as a result of these clashes.
A 3,000-strong East African brigade will soon be on standby to carry out peacekeeping operations under the flag of the African Union (AU). Defense chiefs from 11 nations agreed on Friday in the Rwandan capital, Kigali, to set up the unit. "The force should be able to respond to threats to peace on the continent," Gen. James Kabarebe, chief of staff of the Rwanda Defence Forces, told IRIN on Friday.
Burundi’s political groups have still not agreed on a post-transition constitution, less than two months before planned elections and the transitional period is set to end. Ministers from six Tutsi-dominated parties are boycotting the Council of Ministers meeting that has been in session for the last two weeks to create the constitution.
One of the most important institutions in the fight against corruption and the misuse of public resources, the Office of the Controller and Auditor-General, were broken into last week. The thieves’ vandalized computers holding crucial information, stole 10 computer hard disks, Sh 40, 000 and destroyed documents.
The use of condoms has steadily climbed among Malagasy youth as the government and NGOs increase their efforts to raise awareness about the dangers of unsafe sex. According to Population Services International (PSI), an American non-profit organisation, safer sex campaigns targeting young people were as important as service delivery.
Two years after Zimbabwean troops returned from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Zimbabwe’s public remains largely unaware of the activities of the mission. Government has kept a tight lid on information about the controversial deployment, which was allegedly carried out to prevent Congolese President Laurent Kabila from being ousted by rebels. The United Nations has implicated top generals, ruling party politicians and other members of Zimbabwe’s elite in illegal resource exploitation in the Congo.
Grassroots women organisations have a critical role to play in the development of sustainable healthy, energy efficient and liveable cities, was a common view expressed at the Grassroots Women’s International Academy (GWIA) that opened last Tuesday in Barcelona, Spain. About 30 countries are participating in the GWIA hosted by the Huairou Commission, that is made up of a number of international networks and grassroots groups that are working to bring the voice of local communities to the international arena.
Controversy over a bill to amend Nigeria’s trade union laws surfaced again this week, when a modified version of the measure was passed by the country’s senate. The House of Representatives has yet to vote on the bill, which may also be vetoed by President Olusegun Obasanjo.
In Harare, Zimbabwe, severe water shortages and water contamination have caused many schools to cut short their hours of class or not reopen at all. Without clean water water supplies in Harare, serious health concerns could arise.
There are some places still available at the writers workshop called "Living to tell the Tale", to be held over the long weekend in September in a small town in the foothills of the Maluti Mountains on the Lesotho Border. The question to be work-shopped is, "Does life invent our stories, or are our stories invented on paper?"
Newly revised and updated, this edition brings together, in a single volume, a series of public documents pertaining to Africa's development since independence. These are various resolutions, declarations, treaties, and plans of action, which represent key moments and turning points in recent history from across the African continent. In its entirety, the collection of documents reflects how development ideas and processes have evolved from the early sixties to the present day.
Since Ghana received independence in 1957, student revolutionary movements have made significant changes within Ghanaian political, social and economic spheres. Separate interviews with the former and current presidents of the National Union of Ghana Students (NUGS) show how difficult it has become for NUGS to take independent stances on important issues when everything has become politically divided.
Children's work is currently on the increase all over the world in processes closely linked to globalisation. This book shows how children's work can take on widely differing forms; and how it can both harm and benefit children. Differing in approach from most other work in the field, it endeavours to understand working children from their own perspective. Particular attention is paid to the children's experiences and hopes, especially their attempts to find a public voice and fight together against exploitation and discrimination.
There will be large celebrations this weekend in the Tigerkloof community, near Vryburg in the North West, as it will mark the 100-year anniversary of the Tigerkloof Educational Institution, as well as the return of land to its rightful owners.
According to a speech made by Justice and Constitutional Affairs Minister Kiraitu Murungi, the quality of legal education has declined due to overcrowded schools. In order to deal with this problem, the government must invest in the current law schools by reducing the number of students, approving law examiners, and elevating the school standards.
The Angolan ruling party’s infant wing (OPA) and the Ministry of Education (MED) are going to design a ten-point code of conduct to be distributed to all of the primary and secondary schools in Angola. According to OPA, this code of conduct is aimed to enhance Angolan children’s sentiment of love for the motherland and to rescue socio-cultural values to preserve national identity.
The Supreme Council of the Izala sect, a Muslim organisation founded by Sheikh Ismaila Idris, has approved the establishment of an Islamic University and the school of Nursing and Midwifery in the Bauchi, Bauchi State.
In recent months, tensions and tempers have flared at a handful of school grounds throughout West Darfur's state capital, Al Geneina town, where thousands of internally displaced persons (IDPs) gathered, escaping attacks by Janjaweed militias earlier this year. His rusty crutches resting in his lap, Sheik Al-Dain watched the others line up to receive crucial supplies that would help them survive in Krinding Two, a new IDP camp established on the outskirts of Geneina to accommodate relocated families.
The United Nations Security Council must immediately increase the international presence in Darfur and impose an extended arms embargo to stop continuing atrocities there, Human Rights Watch said in a letter to members of the Security Council. Human Rights Watch also called on the Security Council to establish an accountability mechanism and address serious concerns posed by "safe areas" proposed for the region. In Resolution 1556, the Security Council demanded that the Sudanese government "disarm the Janjaweed militias and apprehend and bring to justice Janjaweed leaders and their associates who incited and carried out human rights and international humanitarian law violations and other atrocities."
This insightful work analyzes the deficiencies of the existing counter-terrorism framework and assesses whether acts commonly referred to as "terrorism" are actually war crimes, crimes against humanity, genocide, and aggression, thereby falling within the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court. Following a discussion of the international law definition of terrorism, in particular the anti-terrorism conventions and international humanitarian law, the author sets about constructing her own working definition of terrorism.
The Zambian government is hosting a delegation of former Rwandan refugees later this month to convince their compatriots to return home, a senior official told IRIN. "We have been battling to convince the Rwandans to go home," said Jacob Mphepo, Zambia's commissioner for refugees. There are currently 6,376 Rwandans in Zambia, of which 4,389 are in refugee camps. Frustrated by the reluctance of Rwandan refugees to repatriate, Mphepo said his office was considering ceasing to recognise Rwandan asylum seekers as refugees.
Sghaira Mint Tesh does not remember the long-ago day she became the property of Arab slave owners. She does not know her exact age, or that of the infant daughter she cradles in her arms. The northwest African country of Mauritania outlawed slavery in 1981, but, despite government denials it still exists and anti-slavery groups say the practice remains widespread.
There were 140 violations of the right to freedom of expression, association or movement in Zimbabwe during the month of June. The Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum also recorded 15 cases of torture and 12 of unlawful detention. For the period January-June 2004, the Forum has recorded 417 freedom of expression violations, 389 cases of political discrimination, 232 of assault and 148 of torture. Visit the website provided to access reports from the Forum.
Booming global trade in rare forms of wildlife ranging from tropical fish and trees to African lizards is threatening many of them with extinction, conservation group WWF (World Wide Fund for Nature) said last Thursday. The Swiss-based body urged governments at a global conference next month to agree to restrict trade in obscure species, which have a high market value as culinary delicacies, aphrodisiacs, or pets.
Refugees returning to Liberia later this year under the auspices of a UN repatriation programme will face starvation unless donors urgently provide more money to feed them, the UN World Food Programme (WFP) has warned. Justin Bagirishya, the head of WFP in Liberia, said chronic shortages in the food supply pipeline had forced him to make a further cut this month in the rations handed out to nearly 740,000 people who already receive food aid.
The Tanzanian government and the World Bank have devised a means of exploiting the country's natural gas resources to increase the country's much needed electrification. A private international consortium, Songas, has built a 200-km underground pipeline at a cost of US $295 million to carry natural gas from the island of Songo Songo to the industrial area of Ubungo in the country's commercial centre, Dar es Salaam.
It’s another case of natural resources proving to be a mixed blessing. While Sierra Leone’s government gratefully accepts revenues generated by the country’s fishing industry, illegal trawling by foreign vessels is providing cause for concern. "We’ve been able to generate close to four billion leones (about 1.6 million dollars) for this year alone compared to about two billion leones (just over 800,000 dollars) in 2002. This is remarkable, and would help shore up our ailing economy," says Okere Adams, minister for fisheries and marine resources. The profits stem partly from fishing licenses and royalties.
The Kenya Human Rights Commission, which has been working with IDPs for several years now, argues that the total number in the country could well be beyond 600,000. This could be the case when you consider that in the run-up to the multiparty elections of 1992, up to 300,000 people were forced to flee their homes in the Rift Valley Province alone.
The Minister of State for Environmental, Lt. Gen. Jeje Odongo, has said despite the strong measures taken by the government, Uganda's biodiversity continues to be lost at an alarming rate. He said there are clear signs that desertification is looming in Uganda. "Our soils are becoming less productive, vegetation is rapidly disappearing and many places especially in the "Cattle Corridor," are now bare following excessive over grazing and deforestation for timber, charcoal and fuel leading to extinction of many plant and animal species," Odongo said.
A mortality survey has just been conducted by the World Health Organization (WHO) and Sudan's Ministry of Health in two of the States in Sudan's Darfur region. It concludes that death rates amongst internally displaced people still surpass the threshold for a humanitarian emergency, underscoring the need for urgent increases in, and focus on, assistance to displaced people in the region. Results show that displaced people, in North and West Darfur are dying at between three and six times the expected rate.
The opportunities for education in public schools are still unequal between Black and White children, even after apartheid. Given that school quality affects returns to schooling and earning opportunities in labor markets, the inequality causes income inequality between Black and White. This is according to an International Food Policy Research Institute discussion paper.
Ministers and representatives from Governments participating in the Western Mediterranean Dialogue on Migration, also known as the "5+5 Dialogue" are meeting on 15 and 16 September in Algiers to work on regional cooperative approaches in the field of migration management. The event, organized by the Government of Algeria in close partnership with the International Organization for Migration, will allow participants from Algeria, France, Italy, Libya, Malta, Mauritania, Morocco, Portugal, Spain and Tunisia to follow up on the "Tunis Declaration", adopted in October 2002 by participating ministers.
Women and children must be prioritised for treatment for HIV/AIDS, appropriate treatment for children must be developed and healthcare infrastructure must be developed as a matter of urgency. This is according to a report from the Save the Children Fund that aims to examine the implications of expanded access to HIV/AIDS treatment, as exemplified by the 3 by 5 initiative, for prevention of HIV in children and young people, and expanding support and care for orphans and other children made vulnerable by HIV/AIDS.
Produced by the International Center for Research on Women (ICRW) in collaboration with UNAIDS, this paper seeks to examine the link between HIV/AIDS and women's property rights. The author asks if women's lack of rights increases household poverty and women's own vulnerability to infection; and if securing these rights can mitigate the impoverishing impact of the epidemic.
The US and the South African government signed a bilateral co-operation agreement in order to improve social development and fight the HIV/AIDS pandemic. Through the US Agency of International Development (USAID), the money will be used to improve housing, education and skills, the judicial system, economic growth and fight the HIV/AIDS endemic.
Jonah Fisher of the BBC Radio and Reuters, based in Asmara, the capital of Eritrea, left the country on Thursday after his accreditation was suddenly withdrawn. Soon after a conversation regarding Fisher’s "racist negative reporting", with the Information Minister Ali Abdu Ahmed, Fisher was informed that he needed a ministry of information permit to continue working outside Asmara.
This article investigates the impact of the spread of HIV/AIDS on the African military and its ability to act as an effective instrument of conflict resolution in the continent. The capacity of African militaries is particularly important at a time when major powers are reluctant to engage in greater peacekeeping operations in the region. The widespread prevalence of HIV among military personnel threatens political and social stability more generally, and this study focuses on the link between peacekeeping and the disease.































