PAMBAZUKA NEWS 79
PAMBAZUKA NEWS 79
Africa's endangered western chimpanzee is the object of an urgent action plan to be announced September 13 by an international group of scientists and government officials meeting in Abidjan.
Malawi has lost $40-million in the corrupt sale of maize, a staple food in a country where more than three million face starvation, a top government official says. The figure, supplied by an official from the country's national audit office who asked not to be named, follows last month's revelation that 160 000 tons of the country's strategic grain reserves had been mismanaged.
The presidents of Uganda and the Democratic Republic of Congo have signed a peace accord aimed at ending three years of hostility. The signing took place last Friday in Angola, whose president Jose Eduardo dos Santos has taken on the role of peace broker in the Congo conflict.
Environmental groups and biotech companies are accusing each other of exploiting starvation in much of southern Africa for political gain as countries in the region try to determine whether it is safe to use genetically engineered crops to relieve famine.
There is growing concern that globalisation threatens the ability of developing countries to address social policy concerns. Is there a need for a global regulatory framework to protect social rights? Should the international financial institutions (IFI) be getting involved in social policy or would a new institution to deal with social policy be more likely to win support?
Of the 21 million deaths from AIDS to date, three quarters were people living in sub-Saharan Africa. AIDS in Africa is fuelled by poverty, and it is causing a humanitarian and economic crisis in which children orphaned by the disease are growing up without parents, schooling or adequate food. What should African governments and the international community be doing to tackle this growing catastrophe?
This paper is a case study into the impact of an export liberalization programme on cashew farmers in Mozambique. The authors argue that opponents of the reform felt that the policy did little to benefit poor cashew farmers while bankrupting factories in urban areas. It presents an analysis into the distributional and efficiency consequences of the liberalization program, and concludes that after 10 years, there was little to show for the reform.
This paper is based on a report by the Commission on Macroeconomics and Health. The main argument being put forward being that investment in the health of the poor would contribute to a wide range of global public goods such as equity, security, peace and a healthy environment.
This book looks at education as a vehicle for rebuilding refugee children's lives, through social interaction and gaining knowledge and skills for their future lives. It reviews the state of the art, identifies key issues and best practices, and aims to assist in updating UNHCR guidelines for assistance to refugee education in developing countries. The five chapters in this book address different issues within the context of education for refugees.
This paper presents an initial framework on how to integrate a gender perspective into all levels of conflict early warning and preventative response systems. The author examines the links that can be made between gender and early warning and identifies areas where the integration of a gender perspective can improve existing models.
The government is to spend 150m shillings [1.8m dollars] to train public officials to fight corruption. Some 970 officers from government departments, parastatals and local authorities will be trained to help combat corruption at their places of work.
Former Zambian President Frederick Chiluba can be stripped of his immunity and face prosecution on corruption charges, a High Court has ruled.
One of the six men accused of murdering Mozambique's best known journalist, Carlos Cardoso, has escaped from Maputo's top security jail. A police spokesman confirmed on Monday to Cardoso's widow, Nina Berg, that the suspect, Anibal Antonio dos Santos Junior (better known by his underworld nickname of Anibalzinho), had escaped from the prison at about 23.00 on Sunday night. No further details of the escape are yet available.
The food crisis has many causes but the most significant according to this report, is the failure of agricultural policies. The paper asks why, after years of World Bank and IMF designed agricultural sector reforms, do Malawi, Zambia and Mozambique face chronic food insecurity. The answer given is that reforms were carried out without first carrying out a serious assessment of their likely impact on poverty and food security. The 'one size fits all' liberalisation policies implemented have failed to lead to growth but have exacerbated the exclusion of the poor from the market.
It was useless to talk about sustainable development when people were starving and when there were poor education facilities and declining health care in a country, said Lucie Jessie Nyirenda of the Economic Justice Network in Malawi.
The New Partnership for Africa's Development (Nepad) endorsed the free trade agenda of the World Bank and International Monetary Fund while failing to acknowledge how harmful these policies had been for Africa. In addition, the plan to boost Africa's position on the world stage was flawed because it had failed to consult Africa's people about the best way to uplift the continent.
Africa faced enormous electricity supply problems in both urban and rural areas, with a large portion of the population relying on paraffin as the principle source of fuel in rural areas, and the lack of electricity exacerbating conditions of poverty.
Naomi Ngwira cannot understand why the whole of Africa can’t survive without Coca-Cola. Speaking at a meeting to discuss global governance and corruption at the Global People’s Forum, a parallel event held at the same time as the World Summit on Sustainable Development, Ngwira asked why more concerted action wasn’t taken against the United States, International Monetary Fund and World Bank over their harmful policies. “Is it really the case that we can’t do anything about the US, IMF and World Bank?” she asked, “Can’t we begin to impose sanctions on the United States?”
Mukarwego Athanasie knows what it is like to be used as a weapon of war. “I am a victim of rape that was used as a weapon during the war in Rwanda,” she says. As part of their campaign of terror, HIV infected soldiers would rape whole villages of women to spread the virus amongst the civilian population.
The refugee crisis in Africa was a major obstacle to sustainable development and needed to be urgently addressed in order for gains to be made in poverty alleviation on the continent.
People from across the world - mainly from Africa - stood up in front of thousands at a meeting on corporate accountability at the World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD) and faced the television cameras to voice their anger at how the negative impacts of globalisation resulted in their continued poverty and disempowerment.
Liberalised international trade would not lead to sustainable development in Africa, with World Trade Organisation (WTO) rules written in a way that benefited rich countries at the expense of the poor.
Developing country governments were continuing to service illegitimate debts that could not be paid without causing enormous human harm, Leslie Fields from Friends of the Earth International told a Global People's Forum meeting on debt eradication during the World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD).
* See the Corruption, Women and Gender, Environment and Development sections of Pambazuka News for more news on the World Summit on Sustainable Development.
* Visit http://www.worldsummit.org.za/ for Commission reports from the Global People's Forum and the final statement from Civil Society.
* See http://enn.com/news/wire-stories/2002/09/09052002/reu_48345.asp for a list of Summit winners and losers.
* The International Institute for Sustainable Development has released a 17 000 report on the WSSD. Find it at http://www.iisd.ca/linkages/2002/wssd/
* Find the two documents that make up the Johannesburg Declaration on Sustainable Development at http://www.iisd.ca/linkages/2002/wssd/0409_l6rev2_pol_decl.pdf and http://www.iisd.ca/linkages/2002/wssd/0409_l6_rev2_corr1.pdf
A Togolese opposition leader and a journalist could be sentenced to four years imprisonment each for "defamation" following the publication of articles saying that President Gnassingbe Eyadema is one of the world's richest men.
Please endorse the Global Day of Protest Against Coca-Cola to pay for AIDS treatment for its 100,000 African workers. Coke is the largest foreign employer in Africa. Volkswagen, Heineken and DaimlerChrysler already pay for AIDS treatments in Africa. Anglo Gold and DeBeers (diamonds) recently promised to do so.
A new South African project is set to revolutionise how AIDS patients manage their anti-retroviral treatment regimes, which often involve taking as many as 20 pills a day. The Cell Life project — a collaboration between the University of Cape Town and the Cape Technikon — hopes to solve the management problem of HIV/AIDS by using a mix of information communications technology, health and engineering expertise.
Penal Reform International (PRI) is an international human rights organisation and is organising a pan-African conference on penal systems in Ouagadougou, on 19-20 September 2002. For three days, around 150 participants including representatives from prison administrations, the judiciary and from the non-governmental sector, supported by international experts from the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), UNICEF, and Amnesty International, will gather and discuss the possibility to find an “African” solution to the specific problem of the use of prison in Africa.
This position is in the Alternatives to Slash-and-Burn (ASB) Programme (www.asb.cgiar.org) whose objective is to identify, develop and implement innovative policies, institutions and technologies that can reduce poverty and conserve tropical forests.
The International Press Institute (IPI), the global network of editors, media executives and leading journalists, has strongly condemned the seizure of issue number 219 of El Qalem, an Arabic-language weekly newspaper.
The Kenyan president has sacked a junior minister and told those Kanu party members who oppose his choice of successor to quit the party. On Monday, the official presidential press service announced that deputy Foreign Minister Peter Odoyo had been relieved of his duties with immediate effect.
Agence France Presse (AFP) foreign correspondent, Griffin Shea's application for a renewal of his work permit has been turned down by the Zimbabwe government, MISA-Zimbabwe has established.
Center for Economic Justice has launched a new, updated website for the World Bank Bonds Boycott campaign. Colorful, easy to navigate, and updated with all the latest campaign developments, www.worldbankboycott.org is a valuable new resource for organizers and others interested in global economic and environmental justice.
The Medical Research Council (MRC) is under great political pressure to toe the party line and become "the trusted scientific voice that justifies unscientific findings or pseudo-science", according to MRC president Dr Malegapuru Makgoba.
Miatta Sheriff and Maima Kromah are six-year old Liberian children. They have lived for several months in a camp for internally displaced persons (IDPs) and have no idea where their parents are. Sheriff and Kromah are among thousands of Liberian children separated from their parents by fighting between government troops and rebels of the Liberians United for Reconciliation and Democracy (LURD) since 1998.
Struggling with one of the highest child-mortality rates in the world, Malawi has launched an unconventional care programme aimed at saving the lives of newborn babies. Malawi has a childhood mortality rate of 104 deaths for every 1,000 live births. The Kangaroo Mother Care (KMC) programme intends to halve that rate.
Persistent wrangling between the executive and legislative arms of government in Nigeria took a critical turn when the House of Representatives last month gave President Olusegun Obasanjo a fortnight to resign or face impeachment. The two weeks have since passed, with Obasanjo defying the motion of the lower chamber of parliament, ridiculing it as "a joke taken too far".
Djibouti President Ismael Omar Guelleh has announced the introduction of multiparty politics to coincide with the 10th anniversary of the country's constitution on 4 September.
A rupture in a pipeline belonging to oil giant Royal Dutch/ Shell has resulted in a major oil slick in Nigeria’s southern Niger Delta, local residents reported last Friday. Residents of Rumuekpe community, near the Nigeria’s oil industry capital, Port Harcourt, said oil from a broken pipe, 20 inches diameter, was spreading through creeks and streams in the area, seeping into farmland and destroying plants and trees.
A week-long fire, which has razed 700 ha of the Kibira forest, in northwestern Burundi, was started by rebels who have been using the area as a stronghold for its attacks on government troops, news sources who have just visited the area said.
At least four out of over 600 diarrhoea patients reported in the Liberian capital, Monrovia, since July were suffering from cholera, according to government health officers.
An outbreak of cholera in Gombe State, northern Nigeria, has killed dozens of people, local officials said on Sunday. Worst hit in the epidemic is the town of Jero Musa in Akko local council area, where 11 people, including three members of one family, died in one day, they said.
Human rights bodies have condemned the alleged "silencing of dissent" and "disregard for the rule of law" in Zimbabwe. Amnesty International said the Zimbabwean authorities were "intensifying harassment of human rights organisations, the independent media and the judiciary", ahead of local council elections later this month.
Four Burundian rebel movements have said they must be included in all ceasefire negotiations with the government.
Unrelenting attacks by the rebel Lord's Resistance Army (LRA) have created a "horrendous" humanitarian situation and stretched local resources in northern Uganda beyond their limits, according to a UN report.
The UN peacekeeping mission in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) has expressed concern over recent advances made by rebel troops and the Rwandan Patriotic Army (RPA) into territory recently vacated by the Ugandan army.
The UN High Commissioner for Refugees, Ruud Lubbers, has expressed "grave concern" over the apparent forced repatriation, since 31 August, of some 1,500 Congolese refugees from Rwanda to North Kivu, eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo.
The office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) has undertaken a major registration exercise for all Liberian refugees in three camps in southeastern Guinea, UNHCR Media Relations Officer Delphine Marie said on Friday.
Thousands of hungry people in southeastern Angola are heading for the town of Mavinga in the hope of finding food, Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF) warned in a statement.
Delegates at the Global People's Forum called for governments to make sure that children have access to health, education and clean water. But for the world's 100 million street children a 2015 implementation date might just be out of reach.
Environment-related diseases and illnesses kill the equivalent of a jumbo jet full of children every 45 minutes, World Health Organisation director-general Dr Gro Brundtland says.
With pupils limping to school on empty stomachs and dressed in tatters, Malawi may not realise her ambition to increase the number of citizens who are able to read and write. Experts have always pointed at poverty as the main reason for the escalating rate of school drop outs. Many of the children are absorbed in the child labour market to help their poor families earn additional incomes to finance basic requirements.
It is now officially recognised by the World Health Organisation, that 80 percent of the people in poor economies rely on traditional medicine for their primary health care. In many countries, the ratio of orthodox medicine practitioners to the population is still very high. A recent research finding shows that resurgent enthusiasm for traditional medicine is leading to over-harvesting of plants from the wild for medicinal use.
In some parts of Africa, traditional healers are the first available person a sick person turns to when facing a health emergency. These healers are often a central component of the primary health care system. In Swaziland, for example, 85 percent of people with HIV/AIDS consult a traditional healer at some time during their sickness. One response to the HIV/AIDS induced African health crisis is that traditional healers are increasingly asserting their role in society and demanding recognition and incorporation into primary health care networks being established on the continent.
Thousands of people are currently hit by famine in Congo Brazzaville. Official and humanitarian sources confirmed here late last month that as much as 32 percent of the country's entire population are starving.
There are indications that following the protracted dispute over who owns the Bakassi peninsular, Nigeria may have deployed troops to the disputed area, to protect Nigerian nationals around the border from possible attack from Cameroun's gendermes.
The Zambian government has allowed the World Food Programme to start distributing genetically modified (GM) food aid to refugees.
Rwandan authorities have repatriated at least 1,300 refugees to Nord-Kivu Province in the neighbouring Democratic Republic of Congo. In coming weeks, an Organising Committee for the Repatriation of Congolese Refugees in Rwanda plans to help 31,500 people return to their homes, the committee announced.
The first batch of 69 people, who sought refuge in Nigeria as a result of the war in Sierra Leone, have been voluntarily repatriated.
Organised violence has reportedly continued to prevail in all parts of the country. The Public Press and the Zimbabwe Human Rights Forum have received a large number of reports on human rights and political violations allegedly perpetrated by the uniformed officials, with the greatest prevalence being reported in Manicaland. This is according to the latest report on political violence from the Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum.
When WFP head James Morris arrived in Nhwali to inspect the distribution of mielies, an unprecedented seven government trucks filled with bags of mielies for sale rolled up, the first time since July that even one truck has arrived to feed the 9 000 people in the area, deep in opposition territory.
Perceptions of widespread racism, and lingering concerns about safety and security, are among the key challenges the Western Cape must tackle to make more of its tourist appeal.
How accurate are the claims of large corporations that they are now environmentally responsible and promoting development? This book examines the debate and identifies areas of progress as well as the limits of corporate environmentalism in developing countries.
There are many difficult questions surrounding the legitimization and protection of human rights in non-Western cultures. This book clarifies in an African context both what ought to constitute human rights and strategies for their realization.
A special gathering of women held as part of the World Summit on Sustainable Development has called for a United Nations Convention on Corporate Accountability to monitor, address and sanction violations by corporations. The final declaration of the Women’s Action Tent, held between 26 and 30 August, demanded that UN conference outcomes should not be compromised in the process of building greater coherence with international finance and trade institutions.
Some 3,000 people displaced by recent inter-ethnic conflict in Isiolo, central Kenya, are refusing to return to their homes for fear of further violence, according to local sources in Isiolo.
The outbreak of meningitis in Rwanda continues to threaten the lives of some 2 million people, and fears are the disease may spread close to the capital Kigali, endangering another one million people, UNICEF said in a press release Tuesday.
The trading house Marubeni Corp. has paid 400 million yen in penalty taxes for concealing about 1 billion yen in income over a three-year period, sources said. Of the hidden funds, hundreds of millions of yen went in kickbacks to Nigeria. Kickbacks were paid after Marubeni won a contract to sell printing machines to Nigeria.
The government of Zimbabwe has "urged" country residents to undergo voluntary HIV testing, Xinhua News Agency reports. Minister of Health and Child Welfare David Parirenyatwa said that knowing one's HIV status is "very important" to plan for the future.
With 5 more days to the deadline for nominations, we are urging eligible organizations to apply/nominate for this year's APC Africa Hafkin Communications Prize for 2002 ' People-Centred Information and Communications Technology (ICT) Policy in Africa'. The APC Africa 'Hafkin' Prize recognises outstanding initiatives using information and communications technology (ICTs) for development.
Internationally known economist Jeffrey Sachs has called for African countries to stop paying their debts and to allocate the funds to AIDS and other urgent needs. "It's untenable to be paying debt that could be used to fight the pandemic," Sachs said in Johannesburg last month. "It's much more than a vicious cycle of poverty. There's a silent holocaust under way." African governments, however, fear retaliation by creditors if they should take such steps.
The Bill Gates of Johannesburg in the gold rush of the 1880’s was reputed to be a Frenchman by the name of Jacques Lebaudy whose level of excess astonished even the stinking rich of the time. Lebaudy was said to have driven a carriage with a harness made out of solid gold, once filled his swimming pool with champagne, entertained his guests with troops of exotic dancers imported from Baghdad and made sure that a new city fountain gushed with wine. English journalist Flora Shaw coined the term “classless excess” when writing about the materialism of the post gold rush era represented by Lebaudy and - more than 100 years later - Johannesburg still thrives on its reputation as a center of smash-and-grab greed.
The Social Movements Indaba, together with many social movements from all over the world, declare that: The World Summit on Sustainable Development, held in the super-rich suburb of Sandton, Johannesburg, has failed. The world’s poor, and the earth’s deteriorating environment have benefited nothing from the Summit. Instead of a lift out of poverty and a healthier environment, the world can look forward to a deepening of poverty on a global scale, and to a further deterioration of the environment.
Gunfire was exchanged as about 70 pro-government militants raided a white-owned farm and barricaded the family inside their home in northern Zimbabwe, says the Justice for Agriculture organisation.
The UN Security Council has decided to keep UN peacekeepers in Ethiopia and Eritrea six more months to give the countries time to mark their border. The Horn of Africa neighbours fought a 2½-year war over the 1,000-kilometre border, a conflict that cost 80,000 lives. The fighting ended in December 2000, when they agreed to establish an international commission to draw the border.
Zimbabwe's opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai warned on Monday of a gathering "people's storm" that would battle what he called President Robert Mugabe's "civil-military junta".
With 5 more days to the deadline for nominations, we are urging eligible organizations to apply/nominate for this year's APC Africa Hafkin Communications Prize for 2002 ' People-Centred Information and Communications Technology (ICT) Policy in Africa'.
ITWeb - Government will prioritise three key areas in its drive to develop Information and communication technology in SA. This was decided at the high-powered Presidential International Advisory Council on Information Society and Development in the Western Cape at the weekend.
Personally, I'd love to get a huge pipe out to the Internet. The true Internet junkie can never have enough bandwidth. But... is it really worth it? Tracey Burrows takes a look at the hype and the facts surrounding Telkom's recent introduction of this service to a few South Africa users. The reader comments are worth browsing.
The World Summit was covered by a number of independent online media portals and initiatives. Take a look at this brief - and by no means exhaustive - list.
Deutsche Bank South Africa has formally launched its Africa Foundation aimed at supporting and uplifting impoverished individuals and communities. Deutsche Bank Board of Directors approved a US$15-million endowment for the Africa Foundation in 2001.
An Orange Farm school has received R1,4-million from Austrian companies attending the World Summit on Sustainable Development, according to Education Africa. The money will be used to build a science, environment and technology centre at the Masibambane College, south of Soweto.
Four months have passed since the Global Fund for HIV/Aids, TB and malaria approved a multi-million rand donation, provoking the anger of Health Minister Dr Manto Tshabalala-Msimang. She met the fund's executive director, Dr Richard Feachem, in Geneva on Friday to discuss her opposition on the allocation of the money to KwaZulu-Natal. But they failed to resolve the issue.
The UK government has granted R330-million to the Department of Water Affairs and Forestry. This multi-donor effort has been pledged over five years to support the UK’s strategic plan to ensure the efficient management of water and forestry resources so that they benefit the poor.
In a seven-year educational transformational programme for Eastern Cape schools, DFID has injected R360-million for the so–called Imbewu programme. The programme includes among other things turning 1500 Eastern Cape schools into self-governing schools. The programme will be officially launched at the JS Skenjana School in Idutywa today.
Despite a damning report on the state of lottery payouts, the head of the National Lotteries Board says the board is doing everything by the book.Sershan Naidoo, chief executive of the National Lotteries Board, said amendments in the legislation, due to come into force by the end of this year or early next year, would make it easier for the board and the Department of Trade and Industry to distribute some of the unspent millions.
The National Development Agency on Thursday handed over a cheque for R200 000 to the community of Msinga in the KwaZulu-Natal Midlands.
The Ugandan authorities and the UN refugee agency, UNHCR, have said they are finalising plans to resettle some 24,000 Sudanese refugees who were displaced from their camp in northern Uganda in early August, following an attack by the rebel Lord's Resistance Army (LRA).
The government of Sudan should end its
recent crackdown on the press, Human Rights Watch has said in a letter to
the Sudanese president. In the past week, the government's National Press Council (NPC) has
confiscated entire daily editions of three newspapers.
The HIV/AIDS NGO/CBO Support Toolkit is an electronic library of resources about NGO/CBO support that have been collated by the Alliance from a wide range of organisations, based on the understanding that there are many viable approaches to NGO/CBO support provision. These resources are accessible on CD-ROM as well as on the website.
In war, HIV/AIDS spreads rapidly as a result of sexual bartering, sexual violence, low awareness about HIV, and the breakdown of vital services in health and education. In conflict situations, young people are most at risk. These are some of the reflections of a report detailing the experiences of the International Save the Children Alliance on HIV/AIDS and its effects on young people in conflict situations around the world.
Professor Makau Mutua, Chair, KHRC
Dr. Willy Mutunga, Executive Director, KHRC
On Wednesday, September 11, 2002, most of the world led by the United States will fittingly remember the tragic attacks on the World Trade Center in New York City and the Pentagon in Washington, D.C. While we at the Kenya Human Rights Commission join the international community in this sorrowful remembrance and mourn for the victims, their families, and loved ones we take this opportunity to call for the respect of the international rule of law, human rights, fairness, and an honest reflection by all states, especially the United States, in its war on terror. We were horrified by the wanton destruction of life and property visited on New York City and Washington DC by last September's suicide attacks. We in east Africa are no strangers to the acute suffering and agony of such attacks. The August 1998 bombings of the US embassies in Nairobi and Dar-es-salaam killed hundreds and injured thousands. While we seek justice against the perpetrators of these horrible attacks, we must never waver in our resolve to respect the rights of suspects. We must never be vengeful or target entire communities or faiths in pursuit of justice. This, we believe, is a lesson that the Bush Administration has missed.
Since the attacks of last September, the United States has pursued domestic and foreign policies that imperil civil liberties and human rights at home and abroad. While the United States has a responsibility to protect its citizens and those who live within its borders, it must do so humanely and within the law. The promulgation of laws to establish military tribunals to try individuals designated as terrorists violate both American and international law, and set a terrible example to countries elsewhere. Policies and official pronouncements that target Muslims and Arab-Americans in the United States violate fundamental human rights. The passage of laws limiting the rights of suspects and their lawyers undermines the foundation of American democracy and invites dictatorships elsewhere to crush their dissenters. As the lone superpower, the United States has both a moral and legal obligation to set a better example.
We express deep reservations in the manner in which the United States has prosecuted its war against terror in Afghanistan. There have been far too many reports of needless civilian casualties. To our knowledge, no one has been held accountable for these killings. We think that such events only help to engender anti-American sentiments, and are therefore counter-productive. We think that the Taliban and Al Qaeda prisoners held by the US at its base in Cuba should be accorded POW status and treated accordingly. We believe that such steps would indicate that the US was acting in good faith in its war against terror.
We do not think that there has been an honest, deep, and open debate and reflection in the United States about the motivations and implications of the September suicide attacks. Instead, the question, "why they hate us?," has been turned into a drumbeat for suppressing civil liberties and violating human rights abroad. We challenge the American human rights and civil rights movements to lead the nation in seeking answers to the attacks, and looking at US policies abroad as one possible arena for reform to alleviate the alienation and grievances that other cultures and countries hold against the United States. We do not believe that the September 11 attacks reveal a neat "good versus evil" dichotomy. Real dialogue between cultures, religions, the rich and the poor, and the North and the South is the only sure way to resolve the demons that unleashed September 11.
We add our modest voice to those opposed to a US military action against Iraq. Since the American-led Gulf War a decade ago, Iraq has been turned into a living hell. United Nations sanctions have crippled the country. Tens of thousands of children have perished of preventable diseases because of lack of medicine and medical equipment. It is the common people of Iraq, and not President Saddam Hussein and his cronies who have borne the brunt of the suffering wrought by sanctions. Any attempt to overthrow the Iraqi regime would lead to national disintegration, prolonged civil strife, and untold suffering by women, children, and the infirm. The warpath must be abandoned. Otherwise it will lead to more suffering and a coalescence of the belief that the United States is bent on the destruction of the Arab nation. Instead, we believe that US efforts ought to be focused on resolving the Palestinian-Israeli conflict -- ending the Israeli occupation of Palestine, stopping the killings on both sides, and establishing a sovereign Palestinian state, with security guarantees for Israel.
There was an outpouring of support for the American victims and families affected by the September 11 attacks. Even a Maasai village community in Kenya presented the Americans with cattle, as a token of its solidarity with the victims. It was a touching gesture. We feel that neither the Clinton, nor the Bush, administration has done enough to assist Kenyan victims and the families of the 1998 Nairobi embassy bombing. While the United States has rightly set up a fund for the victims and families affected by September 11, it should extend some of that caring to victims of the embassy bombing. This would go a long way in alleviating their pain and suffering. It would also show that Americans do not just care about their own victims, but all those others who, in effect, "have taken a bullet for Uncle Sam." On this first anniversary of the September 11 attacks, we want to remember the victims and their families, but also to underscore the obligations of states, particularly the United States, to lead by showing respect for the international rule of law and human rights. We urge and call upon the Bush administration to pull back from its confrontation with Iraq. We believe that only a balanced, internationally inclusive approach, devoid of unilateralism, can alleviate the hatreds and violations that continue to characterize our world today. Otherwise, the law of the jungle will make losers of all of us.
The tragic events of September 11 2001 represent different things to different people. The victims, the terrorists, western, Arab and Muslim governments, Europeans, Africans, Asians, Muslims and non Muslims, people of different political persuasions and leanings, the media, all perceive September 11 differently and all have no homogenous positions on the events of that day and its fall outs. It will therefore be incredulous to pretend that any single individual or group of individuals can speak for Africa or all Africans in relation to September 11.
The one thing that we can be sure of, is that the events of 9-11 as it is now fashionably described, have altered the trajectory of and interaction between international politics, foreign policy, international economic relations, religion, ideology, democracy, human rights and international law. To go a step further, many more people than previously now see how these issues are connected and interact to shape the perception and future of different societies and the world as a whole. In Africa, where slavery, colonialism the cold war, dictatorships and the inequitable nature of north - south economic relations have deepened the problems of poverty, lack of democracy and human rights, it is even more important to reflect on September 11 and its implications for Africa.
No one in his or her right mind will deny that the key problems facing Africa today are those of economic underdevelopment, poverty, lack of democracy and human rights. The proportions are different in all countries but the problems are the same. Without democracy and human rights, the problems of economic underdevelopment and poverty in Africa will never be fully addressed. The question therefore, is how has September 11 impacted on the development of democracy and human rights in Africa.
To a large extent, the reactions to and fallouts of September 11 have been driven by policies of the United States Bush administration and its allies. This is perfectly understandable for reasons that are self-evident. It is important however that in formulating and implementing policy, all governments have a moral obligation to consider its implication for others especially where such policy could negatively impact on democracy and human rights around the world. The available evidence suggests that this is not the case.
Prior to September 11, the rhetoric from a significant number of African governments suggested that even if not fully committed to good governance, human rights and democracy, many of them at least recognised the need to be seen to walking in that direction. After September 11, such rhetoric did not necessarily diminish but became qualified with “recognising the need to fight terrorism”. Many governments which for years have resisted the pressure from civil society to enact legislation, or adopt good practice upholding freedom of expression, assembly, association and other key rights, have suddenly began rushing through “anti-terrorism legislation” curtailing those same rights. In many of cases, the provisions of the laws are so broad that even peaceful and legitimate democratic opposition can be targeted as “terrorists”.
In Uganda for instance the Suppression of Terrorism Bill 2001 imposes a mandatory death sentence for “Terrorists and any person who aids, abets, finances or supports terrorism”. In addition Zimbabwe, South Africa, Mauritius and Egypt have adopted or are at advanced stages of adopting similar legislation that restricts freedom of expression, association and assembly, could define certain peaceful activity as abetting terrorism, erodes the right to a fair and open trial, legitimises arbitrary and prolonged detention, and increases powers of surveillance. Many more African countries are openly considering similar legislation. This in itself is a problem, but the problem is further compounded by the fact that major countries around the world have adopted similar legislation. Several Amnesty International reports document similar laws adopted by the United States, and key countries of the European Union. This in turn has created the international cover for less democratic countries. In many cases, some of these laws adopted in Africa could have been borrowed almost directly from US or UK laws.
The direct implication of this is an “unholy and unlikely” alliance of a variety of governments against civil liberties in the name of fighting terrorism. This creates a fundamental contradiction for instance within the United Nations system where the hitherto champions of civil liberties are now championing the restriction of these same liberties. The US government has also under the USA Patriot Act enabled the Secretary of State to declare as inadmissible into the US persons that may have undertaken activities including advocacy that undermines the Bush administrations approach to the war on terrorism. Considering that the United Nations is situated in New York, and that thousands of human rights activists visit the US in order to invoke United Nations documents in their struggle to uphold human rights, the Bush Administration could end up undermining the UN system in relation to human rights without necessarily meaning to do so.
Add to this the contradiction of key EU governments and the US administration turning a blind eye to “allied” undemocratic governments while condemning others. In the UK Guardian of August 22 2002, US Assistant Secretary of State Walter Kainstener outlined the Bush administrations plans for regime change in Zimbabwe on the basis that the government is undemocratic. The day before, the Pakistani military government headed by General Musharaff a US government ally amended his country’s constitution to give him powers to dissolve future elected parliaments and extend his rule for another five years. The Guardian and other papers also reported this with virtually no complaint from the allies in the war against terrorism. To date the US has not called for the removal of Musharaff [it is worth noting that the alienation of Pakistani civil society can in turn only help Al Queda hide in Pakistan]. Significantly, Pakistan’s earlier suspension from the Commonwealth for Musharaff's coup against an elected government has been conveniently forgotten.
It is an absurdity for major powers to create monsters or facilitate circumstances that create them and then embark on policy u-turns that can only worsen the situation. Without going into the complications of the legitimacy of the land problem in Zimbabwe while condemning Mugabe's methods, such contradictions can only strengthen the likes of Mugabe and undermine democracy in Africa. The International Federation of Journalists in its publication on “Journalism and the War on Terrorism” by Aidan White quotes a Mugabe Spokesperson “As for the correspondents, we would like them to know that we agree with US President Bush that anyone who finances, harbours or defends terrorists is himself a terrorist. We too will not make any difference between terrorists and their friends and supporters ” If Mugabe were to suddenly find himself in the unique position of facilitating a US attack on a neighbouring country harbouring terrorists it is easy to see how such rhetoric would suddenly endear him to the Bush Administration.
If we are to take only one example of the Democratic Republic of Congo, the world can see how cold war politics, the assassination of the country’s democratically elected leader Patrice Lumumba and support for the dictatorship of Mobutu Seseseko by Western governments plunged the country into a crisis from which it is yet to recover after several decades. There is something deeply unsettling about sacrificing the future of millions of people for the convenience of foreign policy. African countries do not need any more of this.
The war on terrorism should not and cannot be fought outside an ethical framework. Any policies that sacrifice human rights for this war will only succeed in fuelling the conditions in which terrorists thrive. The fact that Islam is used as an ideological tool to recruit so called warriors should not obscure the fact that the Middle East is country for country one of the most undemocratic regions in the world. Elections have never been held in Saudi Arabia and will not be held for the foreseeable future. That the majority of the 9-11 hijackers are of Saudi origin cannot be a coincidence. If the same conditions are created in Africa, terrorism, which is by nature a clandestine activity, may well be provided with a popular base that will in turn appear to justify the suppression of democracy in the name of fighting terrorism.
African civil society needs to make it clear in policy and advocacy that they are one hundred percent opposed to terrorism, but also one hundred percent committed to democracy. There is no contradiction in this. There is nothing anti-American about upholding democratic rights. There should be absolutely no doubt that any laws that curtail freedom of expression, association, assembly, and so forth in Africa will be used against democratic opposition and human rights activists. One year after September 11, and, dozens of anti-democratic laws later, no one knows where Osama bin Laden, Mullah Omar, and at least five thousand to ten thousand “graduates” of the Al Queda training camps are. It is therefore important to begin now to call for the immediate repeal of all provisions of anti-terrorism legislation that promotes the suppression of human rights and for a halt to such legislation in Africa. Not to do so may plunge Africa into strife and conflict from which it may never emerge.
Participants at the 10th International Freedom of Exchange (IFEX) general meeting in Dakar have led the way by adopting a declaration on September 11 2002 by condemning “acts of terror and crimes against humanity such as the attacks on the United States one year ago” but also criticising “anti terrorism laws passed in many countries in the aftermath of September 11 attacks” that “include provisions that undermine civil liberties and in some cases severely restrict the right to freedom of expression and freedom of information”. It is important that all national, regional and international human rights and freedom of expression organisations around the world follow this lead.
Sankore is Coordinator of CREDO for Freedom of Expression and Associated Rights.
Thirty years after the Stockholm meeting on the environment launched the era of massive environmental conferences, the World Summit on Sustainable Development ended not with a bang, but with a whimper. The 10-day conference pulled together 9,000 delegates, 8,000 NGOs, and 4,000 media representatives (well below the 65,000 originally projected) in what is widely viewed as an unworthy descendant of the 1992 Rio Earth Summit. The most gracious comment one leading environmentalist could come up with was "at least it wasn't as bad as it could have been."
The UN Children's Fund (UNICEF) reported this week that an outbreak in Rwanda of meningitis, which has already struck two million people, may spread to the capital and endanger one million more.
PAMBAZUKA NEWS 78
PAMBAZUKA NEWS 78
The World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD) will be held in Johannesburg beginning on August 24, proceeded by various civil society conferences and events. Its purported aim is to find a common international discourse, strategies and tactics that allow governments, business and civil society to eradicate poverty, end unsustainable patterns of consumption and production, and combat environmental degradation. But will it flop?
Host president Thabo Mbeki's New Partnership for Africa's Development (NEPAD) is one of the main agenda items, having recently gone through official state endorsement processes at both the June summit of the G-8 leaders in Alberta, Canada, and the July launch of the Africa Union in Durban. Pronounced "knee-pad" by many civil society advocates, the "Partnership" may be a shot-gun wedding forcing the rest of the continent to its knees, bowing to the whims and demands of proto-capitalists, like Finance Minister Trevor Manuel and his Pretoria cronies.
The WSSD will also be the site of a mass anti-capitalist march on August 31, although there are two major camps on the South African left claiming the tradition of the World Social Forum. Regardless of whether a labour/church-backed pro-government grouping--the Civil Society Forum--continues to crowd out the independent-left Civil Society Indaba, the WSSD will not be left unscathed. The latter group has the support of urban anti-privatisation and rural landless people's organisations and until February was the official UN host, before being booted out unceremoniously during internecine conflict with larger, more mainstream groups.
In addition, a variety of NGO side-events by groups like Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth International, the International Forum on Globalization, Corpwatch and many sectoral advocacy groups will keep the pressure on. Security is likely to be sufficiently tight as to prevent disruptions. As many as 100 heads of state are expected, with 60,000 other delegates, press and activists.
Even aside from civil society protest, bad content and process threaten to delegitimise the official event, as happened at the June Preparatory Committee in Bali, Indonesia. The very name "Johannesburg" may go down in infamy as the global elites' last-gasp attempt--and failure--to address a world careening out of control.
The ghosts-of-Earth-Summit-past configured Johannesburg to compromise the environment. The 1992 Rio event did establish the Rio Principles, Agenda 21, the UN Convention on Climate Change, the Convention on Biological Diversity, the Statement of Forest Principles and the Commission on Sustainable Development for implementation. Yet Rio also set in motion third-wayism--championing market solutions for securing environmental protection and promoting free trade as the sole path to sustainability.
Not surprisingly, the German Green party's Heinrich Boell Stiftung recently issued the Jo'burg Memo, which perhaps most eloquently and thoroughly summarises the criticisms of WSSD work to date. Editor Wolfgang Sachs claims that the institutional process has gone forward "without tangible global results. In particular, economic globalisation has largely washed away gains made on the micro level, spreading an exploitative economy across the globe and exposing natural resources in the South and in Russia to the pull of the world market."
Sachs credits elites with only an increase in the global surface area under environmental protection, slowing carbon emissions and declining ozone-depleting CFC production. "Apart from these cases," he continues, "the excessive strain placed by human beings on nature's sources, sites, and sinks has continued to rise. The extinction of species and habitats has increased, the destruction of ancient forests continues unabated, the degradation of fertile soil has worsened, over-fishing of oceans has continued, and the new threat of genetically engineered disruption has emerged."
In theory, the Johannesburg Summit is meant to produce a negotiated leader's statement, a negotiated plan of action and a non-negotiated list of sustainable development initiatives involving states, interstate relations, and business and civil society sectors. But few areas of consensus exist. Several alternative texts, for example, were tabled about the word "globalisation" at the end of the third PrepComm. The US proposed a positive statement, the EU suggested a balanced text, and the G-77/China insisted on a short paragraph that avoided definitions and instead focused on difficulties experienced by developing countries.
More substantive controversies continue over the role of the profit motive, "public-private partnerships" and market mechanisms in environment and development. The WSSD's main problems are its tendency to allow increasing scope for commodification of nature, its inadequate measures to address poverty and excessive wealth, and its orientation to implementation via TNCs, instead of through strengthened nation-states. The major background issue is whether the World Trade Organisation will become the default organisation and set of rules governing Multilateral Environmental Agreements.
Elite capacities to restore both the earth and the social wage have been questionable since at least the 1992 Summit. Then billionaire Maurice Strong, the conference Chairman, helped eliminate the UN Centre on Transnational Corporations, hatched the World Business Council on Sustainable Development and mapped a role for corporations to guide (un)sustainable development. Now WSSD Chairman Nitin Desai has actively blocked negotiations for a side agreement on binding Corporate Accountability, and endorsed the involvement of the newly created Business Action for Sustainable Development Group-which will have a parallel meeting in Joburg in a building adjacent to the government proceedings. Rio inaugurated the 21st century's eco-social war for the planet, the next battleground will be Johannesburg. But what the framers of corporate environmentalism did not count on then was that where there is government and corporate collusion to plunder the environment and hijack humanity, the radical forces of civil society are never too far behind.
* Bond is editor of 'Fanon's Warning: A Civil Society Reader on the New Partnership for Africa's Development' (Africa World Press, 2002) and Dorsey is Thurgood Marshall fellow at Dartmouth University, New Hampshire.
The civic society in Zimbabwe is getting ready to be part of proceedings at the World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD). The focus for some is to be able to link up with the civic movement in South Africa and internationally as common issues are addressed with the hope of sustaining a coherent and permanent civic coalition in the region and internationally. Some are looking forward to making submissions to lobby the leaders of various nations on particular issues.
Angola’s enormous diamond and oil wealth has proved to be more of a curse than a promise, with conflict over resources causing immense human suffering. But increasingly the links between resources and conflict are being made and it is in this context that sustainable development becomes crucially important, argues this article published in State of the World 2002, excerpts of which are printed in Pambazuka News with permission from the author.
Current development approaches often exacerbate existing tensions, create new reasons for violence and undermine conflict resolution mechanisms that are already in place. Approaches based on short term goals that are mechanistic and driven by indicators that fail to take people into account can only lead to increased violence and a breakdown of the very development they seek to achieve, argues a document for the WSSD formulated by the Peace and Development Movement.
It makes perfect sense to link human rights to sustainable development: the right to life cannot be realized without basic rights to safe water, air and land. A human rights approach allows the quality of life of all people to be a central part of decision-making.































